novelty-check
Verify research idea novelty against recent literature. Use when user says "查新", "novelty check", "有没有人做过", "check novelty", or wants to verify a research idea is novel before implementing.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-10-22
- Stars
- ★ 1
- Forks
- 0
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- novelty-check
- description
- Verify research idea novelty against recent literature. Use when user says "查新", "novelty check", "有没有人做过", "check novelty", or wants to verify a research idea is novel before implementing.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Novelty Check Skill
Check whether a proposed method/idea has already been done in the literature: $ARGUMENTS
Constants
- REVIEWER_MODEL =
gpt-6-astra— Model used via a secondary Codex agent. Must be an OpenAI model (e.g.,gpt-6-astra,o3,gpt-4o) - REVIEWER_BACKEND =
codex— Default: Codex xhigh reviewer. Use--reviewer: oracle-proonly when explicitly requested; if Oracle is unavailable, warn and fall back to Codex xhigh.
Instructions
Given a method description, systematically verify its novelty:
Phase A: Extract Key Claims
- Read the user's method description
- Identify 3-5 core technical claims that carry the claimed delta:
- What is the method?
- What problem does it solve?
- What is the mechanism?
- What makes it different from obvious baselines?
Phase B: Multi-Source Literature Search
For EACH core claim, search using ALL available sources:
-
Web Search (via
WebSearch):- Search arXiv, Google Scholar, Semantic Scholar
- Use specific technical terms from the claim
- Try at least 3 different query formulations per claim
- Include year filters for 2024-2026
-
Known paper databases: Check against:
- ICLR 2025/2026, NeurIPS 2025, ICML 2025/2026
- Recent arXiv preprints (2025-2026)
-
Read abstracts: For each potentially overlapping paper, WebFetch its abstract and related work section
Phase C: Fresh-Agent Verification (same-family provisional by default)
Call REVIEWER_MODEL via spawn_agent (spawn_agent) with xhigh reasoning:
reasoning_effort: xhigh
Prompt should include:
- The proposed method description
- All papers found in Phase B
- Ask: "Is this method novel? What is the closest prior work? What is the delta?"
- The NOVELTY VERDICT LIMITS block below, verbatim — the reviewer judges under it
The verdict limits
Copy this block verbatim into the reviewer's briefing; the report in Phase D is judged under it too.
=== NOVELTY VERDICT LIMITS (these bound how you judge, never how widely you search) ===
Search exhaustively; judge calibrated. Two failures waste months equally:
passing an idea a published paper already contains, and killing a viable idea
because the territory has neighbors.
1. Proximity is information, not a verdict. Someone working nearby goes in the
report; it is not by itself a reason to reject.
2. ABANDON has exactly one qualification: a specific published paper already
contains this result — name that paper. No named paper, no ABANDON.
3. Crowded-but-deltaed is PROCEED: state the delta in one sentence a reviewer
could verify. Thin or contested delta is PROCEED WITH CAUTION — say what
would make it carry, not why it should die. CAUTION is not a safe middle:
if you cannot name the specific thing that makes the delta thin, the
verdict is PROCEED.
4. Concurrent or competing work is not a veto. That is a race — report it and
let the user decide whether to run it.
5. A direct attack on a central problem is legitimate novelty when nobody has
executed it well. "This area is hot" does not mean "this area is taken."
6. This check is an early gate, never the last one — more triage, pilots, or
external review still stand between any idea and a paper, whatever order
this run uses. A wrongly passed idea dies cheaply at one of them; a wrongly
killed idea is never seen again. When torn between two verdicts, choose the
more permissive one.
Say plainly when an idea clears the check. Do not manufacture overlap.
Phase D: Novelty Report
Output a structured report:
## Novelty Check Report
### Proposed Method
[1-2 sentence description]
### Core Claims
1. [Claim 1] — Closest: [paper] — What stays unknown or different: [delta]
2. [Claim 2] — Closest: [paper] — What stays unknown or different: [delta]
...
### Closest Prior Work
| Paper | Year | Venue | Overlap | Key Difference |
|-------|------|-------|---------|----------------|
### Overall Novelty Assessment
- Score: X/10 (anchor: 5/10 = has clear neighbors but a defensible delta worth
a pilot; reserve 1-3 for results a named published paper already contains)
- Recommendation: PROCEED / PROCEED WITH CAUTION / ABANDON (per the verdict
limits: crowded-but-deltaed ground is PROCEED; ABANDON must name the paper)
- Key differentiator: [what makes this unique, if anything]
- Risk: [what a reviewer would cite as prior work]
### Suggested Positioning
[State the delta honestly in one sentence a reviewer could verify]
Important Rules
- Two failures waste months equally: a false novelty claim, and a viable idea abandoned because the territory has neighbors. Be brutally honest in both directions — and when an idea clears the check, say so plainly.
- Novelty can live in the combination or the finding even when every individual claim rates LOW — judge the idea, not each claim in isolation. Known parts arranged to reveal something unknown are novel.
- "Applying X to Y" earns novelty by what the application reveals — a non-obvious interaction, failure mode, or insight. Judge the revelation, not the template.
- Check both the method AND the experimental setting for novelty
- If the method is not novel but the FINDING would be, say so explicitly
- Always check the most recent 6 months of arXiv — the field moves fast
Review Tracing
After each spawn_agent or optional oracle-pro reviewer call, save the trace following ../shared-references/review-tracing.md. Write files directly to .aris/traces/novelty-check/<date>_run<NN>/ and record searched claims, closest papers, reviewer route, raw response, and final novelty decision. Respect the --- trace: parameter when present (default: full).
04 同仓库更多 Skills
bio-free-energy-calculations
Performs alchemical free-energy calculations including relative binding free energy (RBFE / FEP+) and absolute binding free energy (ABFE) via OpenFE, FEP+, GROMACS, AMBER pmemd, and OpenMM with explicit lambda scheduling, soft-core potentials, MBAR/BAR analysis, cycle-closure validation, and protocol-appropriate enhanced sampling. Compares ML alternatives (Boltz-2 affinity, DeepDock). Use when ranking analogs by binding affinity beyond docking accuracy, performing prospective lead optimization, or validating SAR predictions.
bio-conformer-generation
Generates 3D conformer ensembles using RDKit ETKDGv3 with knowledge-enhanced distance geometry, MMFF94/UFF force-field optimization, CREST + GFN2-xTB semi-empirical refinement, and macrocycle-aware torsion preferences. Provides explicit decision rules for single vs ensemble conformer use, RMSD pruning, energy windows, conformer count, and force-field choice. Use when preparing 3D ligands for docking, generating descriptor input for 3D QSAR, or sampling macrocycle/peptide conformational ensembles.
bio-admet-prediction
Predicts ADMET properties using ADMETlab 3.0 (119 platform features, including 77 prediction models with modeled-endpoint uncertainty), ADMET-AI, DeepChem MolNet, and chemprop D-MPNN with explicit handling of OECD QSAR principles, applicability domain assessment, calibration, hERG/CYP/AMES endpoints, and PAINS / Lipinski / Ro5 / Veber / BBB druglikeness filters. Use when filtering compounds for drug-likeness, prioritizing leads by predicted safety, or building an in-house ADMET QSAR model.
writing-systems-papers
Paragraph-level structural blueprint for 10-12 page systems papers targeting OSDI, SOSP, ASPLOS, NSDI, and EuroSys. Provides page allocation, paragraph templates, and writing patterns. Use when user says "写系统论文", "systems paper structure", "OSDI paper", "SOSP paper", or wants fine-grained structural guidance for a systems conference submission.
wiki-enrich
Fill in the per-paper TODO sections of research-wiki/papers/<slug>.md pages that literature-ingest skills leave as bare scaffolds. Use when user says 'enrich wiki', 'fill paper TODOs', 'wiki body 補完', '把 paper 摘要寫進 wiki', 'research-wiki 自動填', or after a batch ingest that left papers/ as TODO scaffolds.
web-debug-search
Search GitHub, Stack Exchange, Chinese technical communities, official documentation, and general developer web sources for software errors, compatibility problems, API usage questions, and real-world workarounds. Use for debugging and discovery only; results are not paper-citation evidence.