council
Convene a four-voice council for ambiguous decisions, tradeoffs, and go/no-go calls. Use when multiple valid paths exist and you need structured disagreement before choosing.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 所属仓库
- siddu1004/SFP
- 最近更新
- 2026-11-09
- Stars
- ★ 5
- Forks
- 0
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- council
- metadata
- { "origin": "ECC" }
- description
- Convene a four-voice council for ambiguous decisions, tradeoffs, and go/no-go calls. Use when multiple valid paths exist and you need structured disagreement before choosing.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Council
Convene four advisors for ambiguous decisions:
- the in-context Claude voice
- a Skeptic subagent
- a Pragmatist subagent
- a Critic subagent
This is for decision-making under ambiguity, not code review, implementation planning, or architecture design.
When to Use
Use council when:
- a decision has multiple credible paths and no obvious winner
- you need explicit tradeoff surfacing
- the user asks for second opinions, dissent, or multiple perspectives
- conversational anchoring is a real risk
- a go / no-go call would benefit from adversarial challenge
Examples:
- monorepo vs polyrepo
- ship now vs hold for polish
- feature flag vs full rollout
- simplify scope vs keep strategic breadth
When NOT to Use
| Instead of council | Use |
|---|---|
| Verifying whether output is correct | santa-method |
| Breaking a feature into implementation steps | planner |
| Designing system architecture | architect |
| Reviewing code for bugs or security | code-reviewer or santa-method |
| Straight factual questions | just answer directly |
| Obvious execution tasks | just do the task |
Roles
| Voice | Lens |
|---|---|
| Architect | correctness, maintainability, long-term implications |
| Skeptic | premise challenge, simplification, assumption breaking |
| Pragmatist | shipping speed, user impact, operational reality |
| Critic | edge cases, downside risk, failure modes |
The three external voices should be launched as fresh subagents with only the question and relevant context, not the full ongoing conversation. That is the anti-anchoring mechanism.
Workflow
1. Extract the real question
Reduce the decision to one explicit prompt:
- what are we deciding?
- what constraints matter?
- what counts as success?
If the question is vague, ask one clarifying question before convening the council.
2. Gather only the necessary context
If the decision is codebase-specific:
- collect the relevant files, snippets, issue text, or metrics
- keep it compact
- include only the context needed to make the decision
If the decision is strategic/general:
- skip repo snippets unless they materially change the answer
3. Form the Architect position first
Before reading other voices, write down:
- your initial position
- the three strongest reasons for it
- the main risk in your preferred path
Do this first so the synthesis does not simply mirror the external voices.
4. Launch three independent voices in parallel
Each subagent gets:
- the decision question
- compact context if needed
- a strict role
- no unnecessary conversation history
Prompt shape:
You are the [ROLE] on a four-voice decision council.
Question:
[decision question]
Context:
[only the relevant snippets or constraints]
Respond with:
1. Position — 1-2 sentences
2. Reasoning — 3 concise bullets
3. Risk — biggest risk in your recommendation
4. Surprise — one thing the other voices may miss
Be direct. No hedging. Keep it under 300 words.
Role emphasis:
- Skeptic: challenge framing, question assumptions, propose the simplest credible alternative
- Pragmatist: optimize for speed, simplicity, and real-world execution
- Critic: surface downside risk, edge cases, and reasons the plan could fail
5. Synthesize with bias guardrails
You are both a participant and the synthesizer, so use these rules:
- do not dismiss an external view without explaining why
- if an external voice changed your recommendation, say so explicitly
- always include the strongest dissent, even if you reject it
- if two voices align against your initial position, treat that as a real signal
- keep the raw positions visible before the verdict
6. Present a compact verdict
Use this output shape:
## Council: [short decision title]
**Architect:** [1-2 sentence position]
[1 line on why]
**Skeptic:** [1-2 sentence position]
[1 line on why]
**Pragmatist:** [1-2 sentence position]
[1 line on why]
**Critic:** [1-2 sentence position]
[1 line on why]
### Verdict
- **Consensus:** [where they align]
- **Strongest dissent:** [most important disagreement]
- **Premise check:** [did the Skeptic challenge the question itself?]
- **Recommendation:** [the synthesized path]
Keep it scannable on a phone screen.
Persistence Rule
Do not write ad-hoc notes to ~/.claude/notes or other shadow paths from this skill.
If the council materially changes the recommendation:
- use
knowledge-opsto store the lesson in the right durable location - or use
/save-sessionif the outcome belongs in session memory - or update the relevant GitHub / Linear issue directly if the decision changes active execution truth
Only persist a decision when it changes something real.
Multi-Round Follow-up
Default is one round.
If the user wants another round:
- keep the new question focused
- include the previous verdict only if it is necessary
- keep the Skeptic as clean as possible to preserve anti-anchoring value
Anti-Patterns
- using council for code review
- using council when the task is just implementation work
- feeding the subagents the entire conversation transcript
- hiding disagreement in the final verdict
- persisting every decision as a note regardless of importance
Related Skills
santa-method— adversarial verificationknowledge-ops— persist durable decision deltas correctlysearch-first— gather external reference material before the council if neededarchitecture-decision-records— formalize the outcome when the decision becomes long-lived system policy
Example
Question:
Should we ship ECC 2.0 as alpha now, or hold until the control-plane UI is more complete?
Likely council shape:
- Architect pushes for structural integrity and avoiding a confused surface
- Skeptic questions whether the UI is actually the gating factor
- Pragmatist asks what can be shipped now without harming trust
- Critic focuses on support burden, expectation debt, and rollout confusion
The value is not unanimity. The value is making the disagreement legible before choosing.
04 同仓库更多 Skills
scientific-schematics
Generates scientific diagram drafts using Nano Banana 2 AI with smart iterative refinement. Uses Gemini 3.7 Flash for quality review. Refines when the review requests improvement, with at most two generations. Specialized in neural network architectures, system diagrams, flowcharts, biological pathways, and complex scientific visualizations.
polyhaven-texture-apply
Apply realistic PBR textures from PolyHaven to any Blender object. Supports metals, wood, concrete, fabric, and more. Trigger when asked to texture an object, apply a material from PolyHaven, make something look like metal/wood/marble, or change object surface.
polyhaven-studio-setup
Set up a professional product photography studio in Blender using PolyHaven HDRIs and PBR ground materials. Trigger when asked to create a studio setup, add HDRI lighting, set up product photography, or create a showroom scene.
polyhaven-scene-builder
Build complete product scenes using PolyHaven assets — HDRI environment, textured ground/pedestal, and optional props from the 3D model library. Trigger when asked to build a product scene, create a showcase setup, add a pedestal, or compose a product shot.
polyhaven-material-swap
Cycle through multiple PolyHaven materials on a product and render each variant. Great for showing color/finish options. Trigger when asked to show material variants, swap textures, create color options, show finish comparisons, or render product in different materials.
polyhaven-hdri-showcase
Render the same product across multiple HDRI environments and output a comparison grid. Trigger when asked to compare lighting setups, test different environments, show product in multiple settings, or create an HDRI comparison.