AGENT SKILL

vc-scorecard

Standardized venture scorecard for startup investment review. Converts a loose evaluation rubric into explicit scoring anchors, evidence requirements, weighting, fatal-flaw rules, confidence handling, and recommendation logic.

License 许可
Apache-2.0
所属仓库
cwik-tech/octopus
最近更新
2026-10-27
Stars
★ 0
Forks
0

01 前言 Front Matter

name
vc-scorecard
description
Standardized venture scorecard for startup investment review. Converts a loose evaluation rubric into explicit scoring anchors, evidence requirements, weighting, fatal-flaw rules, confidence handling, and recommendation logic.

03 SKILL.md 正文

VC Scorecard Skill

Purpose

Provide a consistent venture-capital scoring method that reduces impressionistic judgments and forces evidence-backed evaluation. Use this skill to turn startup diligence materials into a comparable scorecard, explicit risk view, and recommendation.

When To Use

  • On any startup investment memo, accelerator evaluation, venture screening note, or internal diligence review.
  • Mandatory for deal-evaluator when producing a final recommendation.
  • Use for specialist scoring whenever the agent is assessing one or more scorecard dimensions directly.
  • Do not use as a substitute for specialist analysis. Use it to structure judgment after analysis.

Core Rules

  1. Separate observed fact, reasoned inference, and recommendation.
  2. Do not let founder charisma or a fashionable market inflate unrelated categories.
  3. If evidence is missing, mark it as missing. Do not silently award a middle score.
  4. A high total score does not override a fatal flaw.
  5. Stage matters. Pre-seed tolerates more uncertainty than Series A+, but not dishonesty, broken ownership, or incoherent market logic.

Score Dimensions

Use these 12 dimensions.

Dimension Weight What It Measures
Coachability 8 Receptivity to feedback, learning velocity, and response to challenge
Team expertise 10 Relevant domain, technical, and operating capability
Team size and structure 6 Whether the current team shape matches the next 12-18 months
Revenue / monetization 8 Clarity and realism of revenue model and early monetization evidence
Financial health 8 Burn, runway, capital efficiency, and financial discipline
Funding strategy 6 Quality of financing plan across dilutive and non-dilutive options
Commercialization potential 12 Product-market fit signals and go-to-market plausibility
Market attractiveness 12 Market size, growth, accessibility, and timing
Competitive positioning 10 Distinctiveness and defensibility versus direct and substitute alternatives
Diversity and inclusion 4 Observable team diversity and inclusion strength where relevant to execution and access
Regulatory and compliance 8 Burden, readiness, and regulatory risk severity
Intellectual property / defensibility 8 Ownership, protection, and defensibility of the company’s advantage

Total possible weighted score: 100.

Evidence Standard

For each dimension, provide:

  • Score (0-4)
  • Evidence
  • Confidence: High / Medium / Low
  • Why not higher
  • Open diligence question

Evidence quality guidance:

  • High: direct documents, metrics, contracts, customer evidence, cap table, legal docs, or multiple converging sources
  • Medium: management claims partially supported by artifacts or credible third-party sources
  • Low: mostly narrative, weak proxies, sparse data, or unverified assumptions

Scoring Anchors

Use real 0-4 anchors, not 0 / 1-3 / 4.

0 — Failing / Absent

  • Material weakness, missing capability, or no credible evidence
  • In some categories, may indicate an immediate pass risk

1 — Weak

  • Early signal exists, but major gaps remain
  • Meaningful skepticism is warranted

2 — Mixed / Emerging

  • Some credible positives, but the case is still incomplete
  • Acceptable for some pre-seed dimensions, not strong enough to underwrite with confidence

3 — Strong

  • Clear evidence supports the dimension
  • Risks remain, but they are manageable and explicit

4 — Exceptional

  • Unusually strong evidence relative to stage
  • Clear advantage or readiness that materially improves the investment case

Dimension-Specific Guidance

Coachability

Evidence: response to feedback, iteration speed, reference feedback, ability to name mistakes, behavior under challenge.

  • 0: defensive, evasive, blames others, no evidence of learning
  • 1: verbally open but little evidence of behavioral change
  • 2: accepts feedback inconsistently; some learning signal
  • 3: clearly receptive, updates decisions based on evidence, strong self-awareness
  • 4: actively seeks challenge, learns quickly, improves visibly, references confirm this pattern

Team Expertise

Evidence: founder-market fit, technical depth, operating history, prior startup or domain execution.

  • 0: no relevant expertise for the problem being solved
  • 1: partial relevance, but critical competence gaps dominate
  • 2: credible domain or technical fit, but execution evidence is still thin
  • 3: strong relevant expertise across core functions needed now
  • 4: rare combination of domain, technical, and operating credibility for this category

Team Size And Structure

Evidence: role coverage, co-founder complementarity, critical hiring gaps, team design for next 12-18 months.

  • 0: team shape is misaligned to survival and execution
  • 1: serious role gaps or founder dependency risks
  • 2: workable for current stage, but near-term scaling gaps are obvious
  • 3: team is well-shaped for current milestones with manageable hiring gaps
  • 4: unusually strong structure, complementarity, and succession depth for stage

Revenue / Monetization

Evidence: revenue model clarity, pricing logic, early revenue, conversion proof, customer willingness to pay.

  • 0: no credible revenue model
  • 1: model exists conceptually, but little evidence customers will pay
  • 2: early monetization path is plausible with some signal
  • 3: clear model with credible early proof or strong pricing logic
  • 4: strong monetization evidence and unusually good pricing power for stage

Financial Health

Evidence: runway, burn discipline, cash planning, unit economics, budget realism.

  • 0: runway crisis, uncontrolled burn, or unreliable financial visibility
  • 1: fragile position with weak discipline or unclear assumptions
  • 2: near-term stability but important weaknesses remain
  • 3: sound burn discipline and credible path to next milestone
  • 4: exceptional capital efficiency and disciplined planning

Funding Strategy

Evidence: target raise logic, source mix, relationship development, milestone-based financing plan.

  • 0: no meaningful funding strategy
  • 1: generic raise intent without sequencing or source logic
  • 2: basic plan exists, but contingency coverage is weak
  • 3: thoughtful financing plan with multiple paths and milestone logic
  • 4: unusually mature financing strategy with strong investor/grant relationship groundwork

Commercialization Potential

Evidence: product-market fit signal, GTM clarity, buyer definition, sales motion realism, customer proof.

  • 0: no credible path to customers
  • 1: GTM story exists, but little evidence it works
  • 2: emerging signal with important execution uncertainty
  • 3: strong early commercialization logic and evidence
  • 4: unusually compelling PMF and GTM proof for stage

Market Attractiveness

Evidence: TAM/SAM/SOM logic, market growth, accessibility, structural tailwinds, venture-scale potential.

  • 0: stagnant, tiny, inaccessible, or structurally unattractive market
  • 1: market may exist, but venture scale is doubtful
  • 2: market case is plausible but not yet robust
  • 3: strong market with credible growth and accessibility
  • 4: exceptional market timing and scale for venture outcomes

Competitive Positioning

Evidence: differentiation, customer alternatives, switching friction, defensibility, speed of imitation.

  • 0: no real advantage; commodity or crowded with no edge
  • 1: weak differentiation or founder-claimed edge not supported by customer reality
  • 2: some real edge, but durability is uncertain
  • 3: clear competitive advantage with credible defense path
  • 4: distinctive and hard-to-copy position with durable advantage signals

Diversity And Inclusion

Evidence: composition of leadership/team, inclusive hiring pattern, access to underserved users or talent pools where relevant.

  • 0: no observable diversity signal and no evidence the team takes inclusion seriously
  • 1: limited signal; not clearly harmful, not clearly a strength
  • 2: some meaningful diversity or inclusion evidence
  • 3: strong inclusion and team diversity that plausibly improves execution or access
  • 4: exceptional strength with clear strategic relevance to company building

Regulatory And Compliance

Evidence: burden level, approvals needed, compliance readiness, legal counsel readiness, documentation.

  • 0: major regulatory blocker with no credible response
  • 1: severe burden with thin readiness
  • 2: material regulatory risk, but manageable with work
  • 3: clear awareness and credible compliance plan
  • 4: favorable position with strong readiness and low surprise risk

Intellectual Property / Defensibility

Evidence: ownership clarity, patents, trade secrets, licensed rights, data advantage, distribution moat, switching costs.

  • 0: no defensibility and unclear ownership
  • 1: weak protection or major ownership ambiguity
  • 2: some protection or advantage, but not yet durable
  • 3: strong defensibility case with clear ownership
  • 4: exceptional defensibility for stage and category

Stage Adjustment Rules

  • Pre-seed: tolerate more unknowns in revenue and financial maturity; do not tolerate unclear ownership, dishonest claims, or incoherent market logic.
  • Seed: expect early commercialization proof, clearer GTM, and a sharper financing plan.
  • Series A and beyond: require stronger traction quality, economic visibility, and organizational readiness. Scores of 2 in core dimensions become more concerning.

Fatal-Flaw Rules

Any of the following should trigger a fatal flaw flag, regardless of total score:

  • unresolved IP ownership or licensing rights that undermine the product
  • cap table dysfunction, founder integrity concerns, or severe governance risk
  • regulatory burden likely to block go-to-market with no credible plan
  • no plausible path to venture-scale returns
  • evidence of fabricated metrics or materially misleading diligence materials

If a fatal flaw exists:

  • default to Pass, or
  • use Invest with Conditions only if the flaw is concrete, remediable, and the condition is explicit and near-term

Recommendation Logic

Use the weighted score, fatal flaws, and confidence together.

  • Invest: weighted score usually 75+, no fatal flaw, and conviction supported by evidence
  • Invest with Conditions: weighted score usually 65-84, no unresolved fatal flaw, but clear milestones or term protections are required
  • Wait: weighted score usually 50-69, or the company needs more proof before underwriting
  • Pass: weighted score usually <50, or any unresolved fatal flaw

Do not apply thresholds mechanically. Explain the override if the recommendation differs from the score band.

Method

Step 1 — Build The Evidence Base

Collect the relevant materials:

  • pitch deck
  • financials and projections
  • cap table
  • legal/IP documents
  • customer or traction data
  • diligence notes
  • founder interaction notes

Step 2 — Score Each Dimension Independently

Evaluate each dimension on its own evidence. Do not let one strong area create a halo effect.

Step 3 — Record Confidence

Confidence is about evidence quality, not enthusiasm.

Step 4 — Identify Critical Risks And Fatal Flaws

List the top risks separately from the score. Risks are not the same as low scores.

Step 5 — Calculate Weighted Score

Use this formula per dimension:

weighted_result = (score / 4) * weight

Then sum all weighted results to produce a total score out of 100.

Step 6 — Form Recommendation

Choose one:

  • Invest
  • Invest with Conditions
  • Wait
  • Pass

Step 7 — State What Would Change The Decision

Name the evidence, milestone, or term change that would move the recommendation up or down.

Output

Produce a VC scorecard in this structure:

## Scorecard Summary

| Dimension | Score | Weight | Weighted Result | Confidence | Evidence Quality |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---|---|

**Weighted score:** [X / 100]
**Raw score:** [X / 48]
**Critical-risk flags:** [list]
**Fatal flaws:** [none / list]
**Overall confidence:** [High / Medium / Low]

## Criterion Notes

### [Dimension]
- Score:
- Evidence:
- Why not higher:
- Confidence:
- Open diligence question:

## Recommendation
- Recommendation:
- Rationale:
- Conditions / milestones:

## What Would Change The Decision
- Toward invest:
- Toward wait:
- Toward pass:

04 同仓库更多 Skills

cwik-tech
cwik-tech/octopus

twenty-year-land-plan

Apply the Bren discipline of evaluating every land and development decision on a twenty-year horizon, with a comprehensive plan for how the land, the community, and the surrounding public infrastructure evolve together. Deals optimized for a five-year exit are structurally different from deals that compound across generations; insist on knowing which kind you are making. Use when evaluating land, entitlements, master-planned development, or phasing decisions, and when separating five-year exit deals from generational holds.

★ 0
cwik-tech
cwik-tech/octopus

thematic-gut-check

Apply the Gray discipline of identifying the structural theme behind every real estate deal, testing where that theme sits in its capital-flow lifecycle, and insisting that deals without a named theme — or deals late in a crowded theme — clear a higher bar. A mediocre deal in a strong theme usually beats a clever deal in a weak one. Use when naming the structural thesis behind a deal, judging whether that theme is early or crowded, and setting the bar the deal must clear.

★ 0
cwik-tech
cwik-tech/octopus

supply-pipeline-gut-check

Apply the Zell discipline of grounding every real estate thesis in the local supply pipeline. Demand counts over adjectives — units under construction, units permitted, units proposed — and convert them into a forward absorption schedule. A deal that ignores the pipeline is a bet on a market you have not actually studied. Use when validating a market thesis, forecasting absorption and rent growth, or counting units under construction, permitted, and proposed.

★ 0
cwik-tech
cwik-tech/octopus

ruin-scenario-mapping

Apply the Taleb discipline of identifying, for every real estate deal, the specific chain of events that produces ruin — permanent, unrecoverable capital loss — and verifying that no single such chain has non-trivial probability. Deals with any plausible ruin path must be restructured or abandoned. Use when sizing leverage, testing refinancing, covenant, and liquidity risk, or checking whether any single failure chain can permanently wipe out the position.

★ 0
cwik-tech
cwik-tech/octopus

revenue-cost-architecture

Design a venture's revenue streams, pricing logic, cost structure, and unit economics so the business model has a coherent theory of value capture, not just value creation. Use after the value proposition and customer segment are set and before financial projections, when choosing a pricing model, calculating contribution margin or CAC payback, or checking whether the unit economics hold at scale.

★ 0
cwik-tech
cwik-tech/octopus

replacement-cost-stress-test

Apply the Buffett discipline of pricing every real estate asset against the cost to rebuild it from scratch. The ratio of purchase price to replacement cost sets a ceiling on long-run downside: below replacement cost, new supply cannot profitably undercut you; at or above it, you are buying a liability disguised as an asset. Use when setting a purchase price, judging downside protection, or testing how exposed an asset is to newly built competing supply.

★ 0