scientific-problem-selection
This skill should be used when scientists need help with research problem selection, project ideation, troubleshooting stuck projects, or strategic scientific decisions. Use this skill when users ask to pitch a new research idea, work through a project problem, evaluate project risks, plan research strategy, navigate decision trees, or get help choosing what scientific problem to work on. Typical requests include "I have an idea for a project", "I'm stuck on my research", "help me evaluate this project", "what should I work on", or "I need strategic advice about my research".
- License 许可
- Apache-2.0
- 最近更新
- 2026-08-25
- Stars
- ★ 0
- Forks
- 0
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- scientific-problem-selection
- description
- This skill should be used when scientists need help with research problem selection, project ideation, troubleshooting stuck projects, or strategic scientific decisions. Use this skill when users ask to pitch a new research idea, work through a project problem, evaluate project risks, plan research strategy, navigate decision trees, or get help choosing what scientific problem to work on. Typical requests include "I have an idea for a project", "I'm stuck on my research", "help me evaluate this project", "what should I work on", or "I need strategic advice about my research".
02 资源文件 10
- 许可证LICENSE.txt10.0 KB
- 参考文档references/01-intuition-pumps.md12.2 KB
- 参考文档references/02-risk-assessment.md12.9 KB
- 参考文档references/03-optimization-function.md17.7 KB
- 参考文档references/04-parameter-strategy.md14.1 KB
- 参考文档references/05-decision-tree.md3.2 KB
- 参考文档references/06-adversity-planning.md4.6 KB
- 参考文档references/07-problem-inversion.md5.5 KB
- 参考文档references/08-integration-synthesis.md5.3 KB
- 参考文档references/09-meta-framework.md16.2 KB
03 SKILL.md 正文
Scientific Problem Selection Skills
A conversational framework for systematic scientific problem selection based on Fischbach & Walsh's "Problem choice and decision trees in science and engineering" (Cell, 2024).
Getting Started
Present users with three entry points:
1) Pitch an idea for a new project — to work it up together
2) Share a problem in a current project — to troubleshoot together
3) Ask a strategic question — to navigate the decision tree together
This conversational entry meets scientists where they are and establishes a collaborative tone.
Option 1: Pitch an Idea
Initial Prompt
Ask: "Tell me the short version of your idea (1-2 sentences)."
Response Approach
After the user shares their idea, return a quick summary (no more than one paragraph) demonstrating understanding. Note the general area of research and rephrase the idea in a way that highlights its kernel—showing alignment and readiness to dive into details.
Follow-up Prompt
Then ask for more detail: "Now give me a bit more detail. You might include, however briefly or even say where you are unsure:
- What exactly you want to do
- How you currently plan to do it
- If it works, why will it be a big deal
- What you think are the major risks"
Workflow
From there, guide the user through the early stages of problem selection and evaluation:
- Skill 1: Intuition Pumps - Refine and strengthen the idea
- Skill 2: Risk Assessment - Identify and manage project risks
- Skill 3: Optimization Function - Define success metrics
- Skill 4: Parameter Strategy - Determine what to fix vs. keep flexible
See references/01-intuition-pumps.md, references/02-risk-assessment.md, references/03-optimization-function.md, and references/04-parameter-strategy.md for detailed guidance.
Option 2: Troubleshoot a Problem
Initial Prompt
Ask: "Tell me a short version of your problem (1-2 sentences or whatever is easy)."
Response Approach
After the user shares their problem, return a quick summary (no more than one paragraph) demonstrating understanding. Note the context of the project where the problem occurred and rephrase the problem—highlighting its core essence—so the user knows the situation is understood. Also raise additional questions that seem important to discuss.
Follow-up Prompt
Then ask: "Now give me a bit more detail. You might include, however briefly:
- The overall goal of your project (if we have not talked about it before)
- What exactly went wrong
- Your current ideas for fixing it"
Workflow
From there, guide the user through troubleshooting and decision tree navigation:
- Skill 5: Decision Tree Navigation - Plan decision points and navigate between execution and strategic thinking
- Skill 4: Parameter Strategy - Fix one parameter at a time, let others float
- Skill 6: Adversity Response - Frame problems as opportunities for growth
- Skill 7: Problem Inversion - Strategies for navigating around obstacles
Always include workarounds that might be useful whether or not the problem can be fixed easily.
See references/05-decision-tree.md, references/06-adversity-planning.md, references/07-problem-inversion.md, and references/04-parameter-strategy.md for detailed guidance.
Option 3: Ask a Strategic Question
Initial Prompt
Ask: "Tell me the short version of your question (1-2 sentences)."
Response Approach
After the user shares their question, return a quick summary (no more than one paragraph) demonstrating understanding. Note the broader context and rephrase the question—highlighting its crux—to confirm alignment with their thinking.
Follow-up Prompt
Then ask: "Now give me a bit more detail. You might include, however briefly:
- The setting (i.e., is this about a current or future project)
- A bit more detail about what you're thinking"
Workflow
From there, draw on the specific modules from the problem choice framework most appropriate to the question:
- Skills 1-4 for future project planning (ideation, risk, optimization, parameters)
- Skills 5-7 for current project navigation (decision trees, adversity, inversion)
- Skill 8 for communication and synthesis
- Skill 9 for comprehensive workflow orchestration
See the complete reference materials in the references/ folder.
Core Framework Concepts
The Central Insight
Problem Choice >> Execution Quality
Even brilliant execution of a mediocre problem yields incremental impact. Good execution of an important problem yields substantial impact.
The Time Paradox
Scientists typically spend:
- Days choosing a problem
- Years solving it
This imbalance limits impact. These skills help invest more time choosing wisely.
Evaluation Axes
For Evaluating Ideas:
- X-axis: Likelihood of success
- Y-axis: Impact if successful
Skills help move ideas rightward (more feasible) and upward (more impactful).
The Risk Paradox
- Don't avoid risk—befriend it
- No risk = incremental work
- But: Multiple miracles = avoid or refine
- Balance: Understood, quantified, manageable risk
The Parameter Paradox
- Too many fixed = brittleness
- Too few fixed = paralysis
- Sweet spot: Fix ONE meaningful constraint
The Adversity Principle
- Crises are inevitable (don't be surprised)
- Crises are opportune (don't waste them)
- Strategy: Fix problem AND upgrade project simultaneously
The 9 Skills Overview
| Skill | Purpose | Output | Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Intuition Pumps | Generate high-quality research ideas | Problem Ideation Document | ~1 week |
| 2. Risk Assessment | Identify and manage project risks | Risk Assessment Matrix | 3-5 days |
| 3. Optimization Function | Define success metrics | Impact Assessment Document | 2-3 days |
| 4. Parameter Strategy | Decide what to fix vs. keep flexible | Parameter Strategy Document | 2-3 days |
| 5. Decision Tree Navigation | Plan decision points and altitude dance | Decision Tree Map | 2 days |
| 6. Adversity Response | Prepare for crises as opportunities | Adversity Playbook | 2 days |
| 7. Problem Inversion | Navigate around obstacles | Problem Inversion Analysis | 1 day |
| 8. Integration & Synthesis | Synthesize into coherent plan | Project Communication Package | 3-5 days |
| 9. Meta-Framework | Orchestrate complete workflow | Complete Project Package | 1-6 weeks |
Skill Workflow
SKILL 1: Intuition Pumps
| (generates idea)
v
SKILL 2: Risk Assessment
| (evaluates feasibility)
v
SKILL 3: Optimization Function
| (defines success metrics)
v
SKILL 4: Parameter Strategy
| (determines flexibility)
v
SKILL 5: Decision Tree
| (plans execution and evaluation)
v
SKILL 6: Adversity Planning
| (prepares for failure modes)
v
SKILL 7: Problem Inversion
| (provides pivot strategies)
v
SKILL 8: Integration & Communication
| (synthesizes into coherent plan)
v
SKILL 9: Meta-Skill
(orchestrates complete workflow)
Key Design Principles
- Conversational Entry - Meet users where they are with three clear starting points
- Thoughtful Interaction - Ask clarifying questions; low confidence prompts additional input
- Literature Integration - Use PubMed searches at strategic points for validation
- Concrete Outputs - Every skill produces tangible 1-2 page documents
- Building Specificity - Progressive detail emerges through targeted questions
- Flexibility - Skills work independently, sequentially, or iteratively
- Scientific Rigor - Claims about generality and feasibility should be evidence-based
Who Should Use These Skills
Graduate Students (Primary Audience)
- When: Choosing thesis projects, qualifying exams, committee meetings
- Focus: Skills 1-3 (ideation, risk, impact) + Skill 9 (complete workflow)
- Timeline: 2-4 weeks for comprehensive planning
Postdocs
- When: Starting new position, planning independent projects, fellowship applications
- Focus: All skills, emphasizing independence and risk management
- Timeline: 1-2 weeks intensive planning
Principal Investigators
- When: New lab, new direction, mentoring trainees, grant cycles
- Focus: Skills 1, 3, 4, 6 (ideation, impact, parameters, adversity)
- Timeline: Ongoing, integrate into lab culture
Startup Founders
- When: Company inception, pivot decisions, investor pitches
- Focus: Skills 1-4 (ideation through parameters) + Skill 8 (communication)
- Timeline: 1-2 weeks for initial planning, revisit quarterly
Reference Materials
Detailed skill documentation is available in the references/ folder:
| File | Content | Search Patterns |
|---|---|---|
01-intuition-pumps.md |
Generate research ideas | Intuition Pump #, Trap #, Phase [0-9] |
02-risk-assessment.md |
Risk identification | Risk.*1-5, go/no-go, assumption |
03-optimization-function.md |
Success metrics | Generality.*Learning, optimization, impact |
04-parameter-strategy.md |
Parameter fixation | fixed.*float, constraint, parameter |
05-decision-tree.md |
Decision tree navigation | altitude, Level [0-9], decision |
06-adversity-planning.md |
Adversity response | adversity, crisis, ensemble |
07-problem-inversion.md |
Problem inversion strategies | Strategy [0-9], inversion, goal |
08-integration-synthesis.md |
Integration and synthesis | narrative, communication, story |
09-meta-framework.md |
Complete workflow | Phase, workflow, orchestrat |
Expected Outcomes
Immediate (After Completing Workflow)
- Clear project vision
- Honest risk assessment
- Contingency plans
- Communication materials ready
- Confidence in problem choice
6-Month
- Faster decisions (have framework)
- Productive adversity handling
- No existential crises (risks mitigated)
2-Year
- Published results or strong progress
- Avoided dead-end projects
- Career aligned with goals
- Time well-spent (ultimate measure)
Foundational Reference
Fischbach, M.A., & Walsh, C.T. (2024). "Problem choice and decision trees in science and engineering." Cell, 187, 1828-1833.
Based on course BIOE 395 taught at Stanford University.
04 同仓库更多 Skills
syllabus
Generates a curated supplementary reading list from any course syllabus using Consensus academic search. Grill-me intake (syllabus input format + course audience + year range) plus a grouping forcing-options checkpoint before any search runs — so the reading list matches the course's level and recency need. Parses the syllabus to extract topics and learning outcomes, searches Consensus for recent peer-reviewed papers per topic, and produces a professionally formatted .docx with clickable Consensus links, plain-language summaries calibrated to audience level, and Bloom-higher-order discussion questions tied to course learning goals. Use when the user uploads a syllabus, course outline, or curriculum document and wants supplementary readings (e.g., 'create a reading list from this syllabus', 'find recent papers for my course') — even casual mentions with a syllabus attached should trigger this skill.
pulse
Multi-source recency research skill that takes the pulse of any topic across Reddit, Hacker News, the open web, and optionally X/Twitter within a configurable recent window (default 30 days). Forcing intake clarifies topic specificity, angle (trend/sentiment/problems/opportunities/comparison), time window, and platform scope before searching. Returns a synthesized briefing with citations, engagement metrics, and cross-platform pattern analysis. Use when the user requests multi-source recency intelligence on a topic (e.g., 'pulse on [topic]', 'what's happening with [topic]', 'what are people saying about [topic]', 'current conversation about [topic]', 'take the pulse of [topic]', 'trending: [topic]', 'find me info on [topic]'), and for competitor research, trend discovery, tool comparisons, and audience sentiment analysis.
patent
Patent prior-art and landscape intelligence skill — not generic patent help. Commits to one of five sub-use-cases via forcing intake (novelty search / freedom-to-operate / competitive landscape / acquisition diligence / litigation prior-art) before any search runs. Searches Google Patents, Espacenet, USPTO, and optionally Lens.org for citation-graph signals. Output is an editable Word document (.docx) with verdict, ranked closest art (claim-text extracted), CPC-class-aware landscape, family-resolved hits, geographic coverage, FTO flags where applicable, strategy recommendations, and full audit log. Use when the user asks for patent searching or analysis (e.g., 'prior art search for [invention]', 'freedom to operate analysis for [product]'). Produces search signal, not legal advice — always recommends consulting a patent attorney before filing or licensing decisions. Trademark, copyright, and trade-secret questions are out of scope.
notebooklm
Browser automation skill for controlling Google's NotebookLM. Use when the user wants anything done in NotebookLM (e.g., 'open NotebookLM', 'check my [name] notebook', 'ask my notebook about X', 'add [source] to NotebookLM', 'generate a Video Overview from my notebook', 'use NotebookLM Studio'). Handles reading and querying notebooks, adding sources (URLs, text, files, YouTube links, synthesized content), generating Studio outputs (Audio/Video Overviews, Mind Maps, Reports incl. Briefing Doc/Study Guide/FAQ, Flashcards, Quiz, slide decks, infographics — discover the exact set from the live Studio panel; the UI evolves fast), and creating new notebooks. Requires browser automation environment — fails gracefully when unavailable.
litreview
Academic literature orientation skill that searches papers via free keyless APIs (PubMed E-utilities + OpenAlex) by default — with the Consensus MCP as an optional enhancement lane when connected — builds a strategic search plan using PICO (default) or SPIDER / Decomposition / hybrid as fallbacks, and synthesizes findings into a formatted Word (.docx) research guide. Grill-me intake (research question specificity + framework hint + tentative depth) before the recon search; a second forcing checkpoint after Phase 2 confirms framework + sub-areas + depth before searches consume budget. Configurable depth (5/10/20 queries) controls coverage vs. speed. Output is a 'launching pad' — an orientation guide that lets a researcher dive in confidently, not a finished review. Use when the user starts literature-oriented research (e.g., 'litreview on [topic]', 'literature review on [topic]', 'I'm starting a literature review on X', 'I'm writing a paper on X', 'help me research X', 'I'm doing research on X', 'can you help me research X'). Do NOT use for single one-off paper searches wanting a quick list — that's a plain PubMed/OpenAlex (or Consensus) query.
grants
NIH grant research skill for clinical researchers. Grill-me intake (research idea + career stage + preliminary data + environment + submission posture + known institute targets) locks down the funding strategy before any search runs. Runs a 5-facet Consensus positioning analysis (with draft Significance/Innovation language), maps the research to the right NIH institutes and study sections via RePORTER, finds NOSIs and funded overlap, and produces an editable Word document (.docx) with budget/scope-aware mechanism recommendations, submission timelines, and a mandatory program officer recommendation. Use when the user asks about research funding or makes any grant-related request (e.g., 'grants for [topic]', 'find grants for my research idea', 'what grants match my research', 'help me find NIH funding', 'grant opportunities for my research'). NIH-only scope — non-NIH funders (PCORI, DOD CDMRP, VA, foundations) are out of scope and flagged at intake.