AGENT SKILL

psych-reference

Use when checking what is live (where replication reform actually stands, and the social-media-and-adolescent-mental-health dispute presented as a genuine dispute rather than resolved, verified August 2026), correcting a behavioural-science misconception, finding the canon, or needing a picker and the red flags to check in any behavioural-science claim. Companion to the other psychology-sociology-cultural-sciences skills.

License 许可
MIT
最近更新
2026-11-15
Stars
★ 5
Forks
3

01 前言 Front Matter

name
psych-reference
description
Use when checking what is live (where replication reform actually stands, and the social-media-and-adolescent-mental-health dispute presented as a genuine dispute rather than resolved, verified August 2026), correcting a behavioural-science misconception, finding the canon, or needing a picker and the red flags to check in any behavioural-science claim. Companion to the other psychology-sociology-cultural-sciences skills.

03 SKILL.md 正文

Psychology, Sociology and Cultural Sciences: What's Live, Misconceptions, and Canon

Part 5 of 6 of the Psychology, Sociology and Cultural Sciences reference (plugin psychology-sociology-cultural-sciences), covering §25–§29. Sibling skills: psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform (§0–§3), psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion (§4–§8), psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity (§9–§15), psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem (§16–§24), psych-twice-exceptional-adults (§30–§42). Section numbers are shared across the set; a reference written as §N → skill points into that sibling skill.

Currency: The core findings are decades stable. Two areas are live. See §25 below for where replication reform actually stands, and the social-media-and-adolescent-mental-health dispute presented as the dispute it is.

⚠️ Read §1 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform first. It is not preamble — it is the single most useful thing in this document.

In most fields you can learn the findings and treat the epistemics as background. ⚠️ Here that gets you a head full of confident claims that are false. Between roughly 2011 and 2020 these fields discovered that a large fraction of their published literature did not replicate, and ⚠️ much of the popular material about psychology was written from the pre-crisis literature and is still in circulation — in bestsellers, TED talks, management training and journalism.

⚠️ GOTCHA boxes mark claims that are widely repeated and either false, much weaker than advertised, or genuinely contested.

The three ideas that organize everything below:

  1. ⚠️ Knowing WHICH findings survived is more valuable than knowing more findings (§1–§3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform).
  2. ⚠️ The robust results cluster in a recognizable place: perception, psychophysics, memory, learning, individual differences, and large-sample demography. The fragile ones cluster in social priming, small-N lab studies with surprising outcomes, and anything that made a good headline (§1.3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform).
  3. ⚠️ Humans are far more shaped by situation and structure than intuition allows — and far less infinitely malleable than a century of blank-slate theorizing assumed. Both errors are common, and they're symmetrical.

§25. What's Live — verified August 2026

25.1 ⚠️ Where replication reform actually stands

⚠️ The reforms work, and the field has not finished adopting them.

  • ⚠️ The strongest positive evidence remains the preregistration result (§1.2 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform): four labs, 16 studies, 64 replications, 55 successes — an 86% replication rate, against the 30–70% typical of large-scale replication projects.
  • ⚠️ Recent estimates of the broader literature sit around half. A 2026 analysis reported roughly 50% of originally significant claims replicating; another put it at 55.1%. Compare the Open Science Collaboration's 36% in 2015.
  • ⚠️ How to interpret ~50% is itself genuinely contested, and the debate is worth knowing. An optimistic reading: most original studies detected effects in the right direction and the problem is inflated effect sizes. A pessimistic reading: the central problems remain — implausibly high rates of significant results in journals, success rates inconsistent with typical statistical power, and repeated failures of headline findings. ⚠️ There's also a live argument that the "right" replication rate depends on your philosophy of science: a field consolidating phenomena should expect a higher rate than one aggressively testing risky theories.
  • ⚠️ A structural analysis argued that pre-reform parameter ranges IMPLY a replication rate of about 36% — matching what was observed — meaning a substantial part of the crisis was a predictable consequence of binary significance-based publishing rather than of bad researchers.
  • ⚠️ The reform is incomplete. Preregistration is still not the norm; reforms are not universally mandated; they do not retroactively fix the pre-2010s record; and incentives still favour positive novel results. One prominent critic's conclusion — that without enforceable field-wide standards, credibility remains a property of individual researchers rather than of the discipline — is harsh and hard to refute.

⚠️ Practical upshot, unchanged from §1.4 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform: preregistered, large-N, independently replicated, with reported effect sizes. Everything else is a hypothesis.

25.2 ⚠️ Social media and adolescent mental health — a live dispute, presented as one

⚠️ This is the most consequential contested empirical question in psychology right now, it is genuinely unresolved, and I am going to give you both sides rather than pick. It is also an unusually good case study in §2.4 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform — what happens when a field cannot run the experiment.

⚠️ The Haidt/Twenge position:

  • Adolescent depression, anxiety and self-harm rose sharply in the US and several Western countries beginning in the early 2010s, coinciding with smartphone and social media adoption.
  • ⚠️ Cross-sectional studies number in the thousands and heavy users are consistently worse off; a 2022 meta-analysis reported odds of depression rising roughly 13% per additional daily hour of social media use.
  • Longitudinal work (e.g. Riehm et al. 2019) has reported high use predicting roughly double the future risk of depression, and these findings were central to US Surgeon General warnings in 2023 and 2024.
  • ⚠️ The "blender study" critique: null results often pool all screen time and all demographics together; disaggregating by platform, sex and age reveals harms that aggregate analyses mask.
  • Haidt and Rausch argue recent work — including experiments run by Meta itself — provides increasingly strong causal evidence, and that harms are occurring at population scale.

⚠️ The Odgers/Przybylski/Orben position:

  • ⚠️ Most of the evidence is correlational, and the effect sizes are very small. Odgers: hundreds of researchers have searched for the large effects claimed, and produced "a mix of no, small and mixed associations."
  • ⚠️ Reverse causation is at least as plausible as causation. Adolescents with existing mental health problems use these platforms differently and more — a Registered Report on nationally representative UK data (N=3,340) with clinical-rater diagnoses found exactly that pattern: adolescents with mental health conditions reported more social media time and less satisfaction with online friendships.
  • ⚠️ The international data don't fit well. An analysis across 72 countries found no consistent measurable association between wellbeing and social media rollout.
  • ⚠️ A selection-effect and moral-panic critique: the pattern resembles previous cycles about novels, radio, television and video games.
  • ⚠️ A pointed methodological objection: a review of the experimental studies cited as causal evidence found that almost all involved participants aged 18–35, mostly college students, and none involved children under 13 — while the policy prescriptions target children and young teens.

⚠️ And the dispute has become adversarial in a way that is itself informative. Haidt and colleagues published a formal commentary in 2026 arguing three widely-cited Vuorre and Przybylski papers should not be used to assess this question, on both conceptual grounds and methodological ones — including Meta's involvement in the research design of one study. ⚠️ Note that the conflict-of-interest concern cuts in a direction worth registering: industry involvement in the null-result literature is a real issue, and so is advocacy incentive in the harms literature.

⚠️ GOTCHA — how to hold this honestly. ⚠️ "Correlation isn't causation" and "moral panic" are both true observations and neither is an argument that the harm is absent. Equally, a coincident time series and thousands of small correlations are not causal evidence. What would settle it — large, long, randomized, platform-specific trials in the actual target age group — is difficult, expensive and partly unethical, which is why it hasn't been done. ⚠️ What both camps largely agree on: effects are heterogeneous rather than universal; girls and early adolescents appear more affected; what you do on a platform matters more than time spent; and displacement of sleep, exercise and in-person contact is a plausible mechanism independent of content. ⚠️ Anyone presenting this as settled in either direction is telling you about their priors.


§26. Misconceptions

Misconception Correction
Most published psychology findings are solid ⚠️ ~36% replicated in 2015; ~50–55% in recent estimates (§1 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform, §25.1)
The replication crisis means psychology is fake ⚠️ Preregistered studies replicated at 86% (§1.2 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform)
Learning styles (visual/auditory/kinesthetic) ⚠️ No support. Repeatedly tested, repeatedly failed (§1.3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform)
Ego depletion / willpower as a fuel tank ⚠️ Failed large multi-lab replication (§7 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion)
Power posing changes hormones and outcomes ⚠️ Did not replicate (§1.3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform)
Social priming effects are established ⚠️ Broad replication failure as a programme (§12 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
The Stanford Prison Experiment shows situational power ⚠️ Methodologically compromised; not usable evidence (§12 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
The IAT measures your personal bias ⚠️ Poor individual reliability and weak behaviour prediction (§12 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
MBTI tells you your personality type ⚠️ Poor reliability, false dichotomies, no predictive validity (§10 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
People are introverts or extraverts ⚠️ Continuous distribution, not types (§10 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Memory is a recording ⚠️ Reconstructive; false memories are readily created (§5 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion)
Confident eyewitnesses are accurate ⚠️ Confidence tracks accuracy poorly, especially post-feedback (§5 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion)
Re-reading and highlighting are good study methods ⚠️ Among the weakest. Use retrieval practice and spacing (§5 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion)
We use 10% of our brains ⚠️ Straightforwardly false
Left-brained / right-brained people ⚠️ Not a thing as popularly described
It takes 21 days to form a habit ⚠️ No good basis; actual research found much longer and highly variable (§6 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion)
Growth mindset produces large gains ⚠️ Effects far smaller than claimed (§11 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Different therapies differ greatly in effectiveness ⚠️ Broadly similar, except exposure for anxiety/OCD (§13 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Depression is a chemical imbalance ⚠️ Not supported as stated; medication can still work (§13 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Heritability means fixed or unchangeable ⚠️ Population variance statistic; Flynn effect disproves it (§14 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Heritability within groups explains gaps between groups ⚠️ Invalid inference. The most common error in the area (§14 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Multiple intelligences is established ⚠️ Popular; not supported psychometrically (§14 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Social construction means "not real" ⚠️ Constructed things have material consequences (§16 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Broken windows policing is evidence-based ⚠️ Much weaker support than its policy uptake (§21 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Severe punishment deters crime ⚠️ Certainty deters; severity much less (§21 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Modernization inevitably produces secularization ⚠️ Substantially revised; one regional trajectory (§22 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Hofstede's dimensions measure a person's culture ⚠️ Country-level aggregates; applying to individuals is an ecological fallacy (§24 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Psychology findings describe humans ⚠️ They mostly describe WEIRD samples (§24 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Social media's harm to teens is settled ⚠️ Genuinely contested. See both cases (§25.2)

§27. Books

⚠️ Epistemics first — read these before the content books:

Author Work Why
Ritchie Science Fictions ⚠️ The best accessible account of §1–§3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform. Start here
Chivers Everything Is Predictable Bayesian reasoning applied to exactly these problems
Meehl "Why Summaries of Research… Are Often Uninterpretable" ⚠️ He diagnosed all of this in 1978. Chilling

Psychology | Kahneman | Thinking, Fast and Slow | ⚠️ Foundational AND partly superseded — read with §7 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion in hand | | Barrett | How Emotions Are Made | §8 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion's constructionist case, argued strongly | | Loftus | Eyewitness Testimony | §5 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion | | Nettle | Personality | ⚠️ Short, honest Big Five treatment | | Brown, Roediger & McDaniel | Make It Stick | ⚠️ §5 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion's learning findings, practically |

Sociology and anthropology | Mills | The Sociological Imagination | The founding statement of the discipline's move | | Goffman | The Presentation of Self | ⚠️ Still the most useful single sociology book | | Bourdieu | Distinction | §17–§18 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem. Difficult and worth it | | Granovetter | "The Strength of Weak Ties" (1973) | ⚠️ One paper, enormous payoff (§19 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem) | | Geertz | The Interpretation of Cultures | §23 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem | | Henrich | The Secret of Our Success / The WEIRDest People | ⚠️ §24 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem. The best cultural-evolution case | | Scott | Seeing Like a State | ⚠️ Institutions, legibility, and why schemes fail (§20 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem) |


§28. Quick Reference

28.1 Picker

Question Where
Should I believe this psychology claim? ⚠️ §1.4 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform's checklist. Preregistered? Replicated? Effect size?
Is this finding in the robust tier? ⚠️ §1.3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform
How do I actually learn something? ⚠️ Retrieval practice + spacing (§5 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion)
Which personality test? ⚠️ A validated Big Five inventory. Not MBTI (§10 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Does therapy work, and which? ⚠️ Yes; mostly alliance and therapist, except exposure (§13 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Is intelligence heritable / fixed? ⚠️ Heritable ≠ fixed. Flynn effect (§14 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity)
Why did this group outcome happen? ⚠️ Look at structure and networks before intentions (§16 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem, §19 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
How do I find a job / novel information? ⚠️ Weak ties (§19 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Why do these organizations all do the same thing? ⚠️ Isomorphism (§20 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Does this generalize beyond the sample? ⚠️ Probably not — WEIRD (§24 → psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem)
Is social media harming teenagers? ⚠️ Genuinely unsettled. §25.2

28.2 ⚠️ Red flags in any behavioural-science claim

  • [ ] ⚠️ Small sample with a surprising result
  • [ ] ⚠️ Published pre-2015 and never independently replicated
  • [ ] ⚠️ Effect size not reported, or reported only as p<.05
  • [ ] ⚠️ A single study carrying a large policy or product recommendation
  • [ ] ⚠️ Correlational data described with causal verbs
  • [ ] ⚠️ A tidy mechanism story that outruns the data
  • [ ] ⚠️ WEIRD sample, universal claim
  • [ ] ⚠️ The researcher has a book, a consultancy, or a training programme built on it
  • [ ] ⚠️ It's counterintuitive, memorable, and everyone has heard of it

§29. Method

§1–§24 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform, psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion, psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity, psych-sociology-institutions-culture-and-the-weird-problem rest on stable material — the replication literature, the psychometric findings, classical sociological theory, and the cross-cultural work — sourced from §27. ⚠️ None of it needed verification.

Two searches were run in August 2026, on the current state of replication reform and the social media/adolescent mental health dispute — ⚠️ the two places where a static answer would misrepresent an active situation.

Confidence. High in §1–§3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform, which I consider the most valuable part of this document. ⚠️ The structural decision to put epistemics FIRST rather than in an appendix is deliberate: in this domain, knowing which findings survived is worth more than knowing more findings, and most popular material about psychology draws on the pre-crisis literature without flagging it.

High in §1.2 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform's numbers — the Open Science Collaboration's 36% and the preregistration study's 86% (55 of 64 replications across four labs and 16 studies) are both well documented — ⚠️ and I'd emphasise that the second is the more important and less known. Recent broader estimates around 50–55% come from 2026 analyses, and I've included the genuine disagreement about how to interpret that figure rather than presenting one reading.

High in the specific replication successes and failures listed in §1.3 → psych-epistemic-situation-and-replication-reform, §7 → psych-perception-memory-learning-cognition-and-emotion, §11 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity and §12 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity. ⚠️ These are individually well documented, and I've tried to be precise about degree — "failed replication" for ego depletion and social priming, "much weaker than claimed" for growth mindset and stereotype threat, "methodologically compromised" for Stanford Prison. Those are different claims and collapsing them would be unfair in both directions.

⚠️ §25.2 is presented as an unresolved dispute because it is one, and that is a deliberate choice rather than fence-sitting. I've given each side its strongest form with its actual evidence — the meta-analytic odds ratio and the disaggregation critique on one side; the 72-country null, the Registered Report on reverse causation, and the age-mismatch objection on the other. ⚠️ Both camps include serious researchers, both have made valid criticisms of the other, and both operate under conflict-of-interest pressures pointing opposite ways — industry involvement in some null-result work, advocacy incentives in some harms work. I've flagged both. If you want my honest read on where the burden sits: the population-level causal claim is not established, the small-effects finding is well supported, and neither of those facts means the harm is zero for the subgroups most affected.

⚠️ §14 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity and §15 → psych-development-personality-social-clinical-and-neurodiversity were written with deliberate care — stating what is well established and what is not, and specifically flagging the within-group/between-group heritability inference as invalid, because that is where public discussion most often goes wrong in both directions.

⚠️ Sourcing caution: the replication-reform material includes advocacy from both reformers and defenders of the published record, and the social-media material includes a great deal from partisans with books and public positions. Where I could anchor on a Registered Report, a Nature or Science piece, or a large multi-lab project, I did.

04 同仓库更多 Skills

the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

white-paper-writing

Use when writing white papers, technical reports, policy documents, thought leadership pieces, or any long-form authoritative document. Triggers on requests to write, structure, outline, or review white papers, technical reports, position papers, policy briefs, or evidence-driven arguments. Also use for B2B content marketing strategy, technical documentation requiring authority, academic-style reports, or any document that must educate while persuading. Use when someone asks "how should I structure this" for a long-form document.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

prose-technical-mechanics

Use when editing or writing prose at a technical/mechanical level: choosing between Anglo-Saxon and Latinate diction, placing information in topic vs stress positions, writing periodic vs cumulative sentences, handling sentence rhythm, punctuation as logic, transitions, paragraph structure, or phonesthetics. Use when someone wants to understand WHY prose works or doesn't, not just surface-level style advice. Triggers on word choice, sentence structure, emphasis, rhythm, diction, or any deep writing mechanics question.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

prose-mechanics

Use when writing, editing, or analyzing prose style; when trying to avoid generic AI-sounding writing; when applying specific prose styles such as journalistic, academic, narrative, KJV biblical, Hemingway plain, Latinate/Jamesian, Orwellian, Augustan, Victorian, Early Modern (Bacon, Browne, Milton), or free indirect discourse; or when coaching someone on writing voice and mechanics. Triggers on any request to improve, analyze, or write in a specific prose style, to fix "AI-sounding" writing, to make prose more vivid or concrete, to vary sentence rhythm, or to understand how a particular writer achieves their effects.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

narrative-structure

Use when structuring stories, pitches, presentations, white papers, or any persuasive narrative; analyzing the hero's journey in fiction or non-fiction; applying StoryBrand for business communication; designing narrative arcs for thought leadership; or understanding Vogler, Snyder, Propp, or Campbell frameworks. Triggers on any narrative structure, storytelling, pitch structure, StoryBrand, hero's journey, three-act structure, Freytag, Save the Cat, narrative arc, or "how should I structure this story/pitch/presentation" request.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

legal-brief-writing

Use when writing legal briefs, motions, or any court filing; when analyzing judicial cognition and persuasion; when applying elite brief-writing techniques from Roberts, Clement, Kagan, Garner; or when structuring legal arguments for maximum persuasion. Also use for autistic/neurodivergent advocates who need to understand how their natural communication style maps to elite legal advocacy. Triggers on any legal writing, brief drafting, motion preparation, or legal argument structuring request.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

journal-publishability-criteria

Use whenever a research paper, article or preprint is being written, revised, reviewed or published, and specifically before every publication of docs/paper.md. Covers what legitimate journals actually gate on, in order of gating — the editor's desk screen (scope, novelty, package problems), what reviewers judge (methodological soundness, claims the evidence can carry, statistical and qualitative reporting), EQUATOR reporting guidelines, the ICMJE authorship criteria, COPE's view of text recycling, the near-universal generative-AI policy (no AI author, disclosure, author responsibility), TOP 2025 transparency standards, how to verify a journal is legitimate, submitting without an institution, and a pre-submission checklist. Triggers on requests to evaluate, review, prepare or submit a paper, to judge publishability, to write a declarations or data-availability section, to disclose AI use, or to check a journal.

★ 5