polisci-collective-action-commons-social-choice-and-voting
Use for the formal core that generalises well beyond politics: collective action problems and free riding, the commons and Ostrom's correction showing when communities do successfully self-govern, social choice including Arrow's and Gibbard-Satterthwaite's impossibility results and what they actually rule out, and voting systems with their real properties and failure modes.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-11-15
- Stars
- ★ 5
- Forks
- 3
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- polisci-collective-action-commons-social-choice-and-voting
- description
- Use for the formal core that generalises well beyond politics: collective action problems and free riding, the commons and Ostrom's correction showing when communities do successfully self-govern, social choice including Arrow's and Gibbard-Satterthwaite's impossibility results and what they actually rule out, and voting systems with their real properties and failure modes.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Political Science and Governance: Collective Action Problems, the Commons and Ostrom's Correction, Social Choice, and Voting Systems
Part 2 of 6 of the Political Science, Human Systems and Governance reference (plugin
political-science-human-systems-governance), covering §5–§8. Sibling skills:polisci-what-the-field-establishes-power-the-state-and-theory(§0–§4),polisci-constitutional-design-electoral-systems-and-institutions(§9–§13),polisci-bureaucracy-parties-voter-behaviour-and-polarization(§14–§18),polisci-regimes-state-capacity-corruption-ir-and-field-problems(§19–§25),polisci-reference(§26–§31). Section numbers are shared across the set; a reference written as §N →skillpoints into that sibling skill.Currency: The theory is stable. Two areas are live. See §26 →
polisci-referencefor current democracy measurement, and the scholarly dispute about whether those measurements are reliable.
⚠️ A note on how this document handles contested questions. ⚠️ Political science contains robust empirical findings, contested empirical findings, and normative disputes that evidence cannot settle. This document tries to say which is which (§1 →
polisci-what-the-field-establishes-power-the-state-and-theory), and where a question is genuinely contested it presents the strongest version of more than one position rather than picking. ⚠️ Where I report a finding, I attribute it; where scholars disagree, I say so.Complements a civil/industrial engineering reference (institutions as accumulated failure logs), a pedagogy reference (evidence quality in social science), and an economics-adjacent treatment of collective action.
⚠️ GOTCHA boxes mark the results that are counterintuitive or routinely misstated.
The three ideas that organize this document:
- ⚠️ COLLECTIVE ACTION PROBLEMS are the discipline's deepest structure (§5–§6). Individually rational behaviour producing collectively bad outcomes explains government, taxation, regulation, unions, cartels and treaties — and Ostrom's work showed the standard remedies are not the only ones.
- ⚠️ INSTITUTIONS SHAPE BEHAVIOUR, and the effects are often perverse (§9–§15 →
polisci-constitutional-design-electoral-systems-and-institutions,polisci-bureaucracy-parties-voter-behaviour-and-polarization). Electoral rules, veto points and federal structures produce predictable consequences that designers frequently did not intend.- ⚠️ MEASUREMENT IS THE FIELD'S BINDING CONSTRAINT (§25 →
polisci-regimes-state-capacity-corruption-ir-and-field-problems, §26 →polisci-reference). Most interesting political concepts — democracy, power, legitimacy, polarization — are hard to measure, and disputes that look substantive are often measurement disputes underneath.
§5. ⚠️ Collective Action Problems
⚠️ The deepest structure in the discipline: situations where individually rational behaviour produces collectively worse outcomes for everyone.
⚠️ PRISONER'S DILEMMA ⚠️ defection dominates individually,
mutual cooperation is better for both. ⚠️ ITERATION changes
this — Axelrod showed reciprocal strategies do well in repeated
play, so the SHADOW OF THE FUTURE is what sustains cooperation
⚠️ PUBLIC GOODS ⚠️ non-rival and non-excludable → free riding →
undersupply. ⚠️ The standard justification for taxation
⚠️ OLSON'S LOGIC ⚠️ SMALL CONCENTRATED groups organize more
easily than large diffuse ones. ⚠️ THEREFORE policy tends to
favour concentrated interests over diffuse ones even under
perfect democracy — this is the structural explanation for
why narrow benefits and dispersed costs are so common
⚠️ Hence SELECTIVE INCENTIVES: unions and professional bodies
supply private benefits to fund the collective good
⚠️ COORDINATION problems (a focal point suffices) are DIFFERENT
from cooperation problems (⚠️ enforcement is needed)
⚠️ PRINCIPAL-AGENT ⚠️ voters→politicians→bureaucrats→street level.
Information asymmetry at every link (§14)
⚠️ TIME INCONSISTENCY ⚠️ today's government cannot bind tomorrow's,
which is why independent central banks and constitutional
entrenchment exist
§6. ⚠️ The Commons, and Ostrom's Correction
⚠️ Hardin's "Tragedy of the Commons" (1968) argued shared resources are inevitably overexploited, and that the remedies are privatization or state control.
⚠️ GOTCHA — Ostrom's Nobel-winning work substantially overturned the "inevitably" part, and this is one of the field's genuinely important empirical corrections. ⚠️ Ostrom documented many real, durable common-pool resource regimes — irrigation systems, fisheries, alpine pastures, forests — governed successfully for centuries by the users themselves, with neither privatization nor state control. ⚠️ She also noted Hardin's example was an OPEN ACCESS resource, not a managed commons, and the two are different things.
⚠️ Ostrom's design principles for enduring commons institutions (⚠️ empirically derived, not deduced): ⚠️ clearly defined boundaries; rules matched to local conditions; collective-choice arrangements letting users modify their own rules; monitoring by accountable monitors; GRADUATED sanctions; accessible conflict resolution; recognized rights to organize; and nested enterprises for larger systems. ⚠️ The general lesson is broader than commons: ⚠️ there is frequently a third option between market and state, and institutional solutions that emerge locally can outperform imposed ones — while also being vulnerable to scale, mobility and outside pressure.
§7. ⚠️ Social Choice
⚠️ CONDORCET PARADOX ⚠️ majority preferences can CYCLE: a majority
prefers A to B, B to C, and C to A. ⚠️ "The will of the majority"
may not exist as a coherent object
⚠️ ARROW'S IMPOSSIBILITY THEOREM ⚠️ a PROOF, not an empirical
finding. No ranked voting rule over three or more options can
simultaneously satisfy a short list of reasonable conditions
(unrestricted domain, non-dictatorship, Pareto,
independence of irrelevant alternatives)
⚠️ WHAT IT DOES NOT MEAN: it does NOT show voting is pointless
or that all systems are equally bad. ⚠️ It shows no system is
perfect on those axioms — which is a claim about trade-offs
⚠️ GIBBARD-SATTERTHWAITE ⚠️ every reasonable voting system is
manipulable in principle. ⚠️ Strategic voting cannot be
designed away
⚠️ MEDIAN VOTER THEOREM ⚠️ under restrictive assumptions
(one dimension, single-peaked preferences, two competitors),
both converge on the median. ⚠️ Real politics is
multidimensional, so treat it as a tendency, not a law
⚠️ MCKELVEY CHAOS THEOREM ⚠️ in multiple dimensions, agenda
control can lead majority rule almost anywhere. ⚠️ Which
makes §2's second face of power a formal result
§8. ⚠️ Voting Systems
⚠️ There is no neutral voting system. Every rule embeds a judgement about what representation means.
⚠️ FPTP / plurality ⚠️ simple, produces single-party majorities,
strong local link. ⚠️ Disproportionate; wasted votes; rewards
geographic concentration; ⚠️ can elect a legislature whose
majority won a minority of votes
⚠️ TWO-ROUND majority for the winner; ⚠️ costly, and can produce
perverse first-round eliminations
⚠️ RANKED CHOICE / IRV / AV ⚠️ eliminates the spoiler problem
partially; ⚠️ NOT monotonic in all cases (⚠️ ranking a candidate
HIGHER can in principle hurt them — a real theoretical defect)
⚠️ LIST PR proportional, ⚠️ coalition government the norm,
thresholds exclude small parties; ⚠️ weaker constituency link
⚠️ MMP ⚠️ combines local members with a proportional correction
STV proportional with ranked ballots in multi-member seats
APPROVAL and SCORE ⚠️ escape Arrow's framing by not being
ranked systems — which is why advocates favour them, and
they face Gibbard-Satterthwaite regardless
⚠️ DUVERGER'S LAW is among the more robust findings (§1 → polisci-what-the-field-establishes-power-the-state-and-theory): ⚠️ plurality single-member
districts TEND toward two-party competition, through the mechanical effect (seats punish
small parties) and the psychological effect (voters abandon them). ⚠️ Stated as a
tendency, not a law — India and Canada are standing qualifications.
⚠️ Malapportionment and gerrymandering — ⚠️ and note that the requirement of
proportionality, compactness, competitiveness, and respect for communities of interest
CANNOT all be satisfied simultaneously, which is why redistricting is genuinely hard and
not merely corrupt.
PART III — INSTITUTIONS
04 同仓库更多 Skills
white-paper-writing
Use when writing white papers, technical reports, policy documents, thought leadership pieces, or any long-form authoritative document. Triggers on requests to write, structure, outline, or review white papers, technical reports, position papers, policy briefs, or evidence-driven arguments. Also use for B2B content marketing strategy, technical documentation requiring authority, academic-style reports, or any document that must educate while persuading. Use when someone asks "how should I structure this" for a long-form document.
prose-technical-mechanics
Use when editing or writing prose at a technical/mechanical level: choosing between Anglo-Saxon and Latinate diction, placing information in topic vs stress positions, writing periodic vs cumulative sentences, handling sentence rhythm, punctuation as logic, transitions, paragraph structure, or phonesthetics. Use when someone wants to understand WHY prose works or doesn't, not just surface-level style advice. Triggers on word choice, sentence structure, emphasis, rhythm, diction, or any deep writing mechanics question.
prose-mechanics
Use when writing, editing, or analyzing prose style; when trying to avoid generic AI-sounding writing; when applying specific prose styles such as journalistic, academic, narrative, KJV biblical, Hemingway plain, Latinate/Jamesian, Orwellian, Augustan, Victorian, Early Modern (Bacon, Browne, Milton), or free indirect discourse; or when coaching someone on writing voice and mechanics. Triggers on any request to improve, analyze, or write in a specific prose style, to fix "AI-sounding" writing, to make prose more vivid or concrete, to vary sentence rhythm, or to understand how a particular writer achieves their effects.
narrative-structure
Use when structuring stories, pitches, presentations, white papers, or any persuasive narrative; analyzing the hero's journey in fiction or non-fiction; applying StoryBrand for business communication; designing narrative arcs for thought leadership; or understanding Vogler, Snyder, Propp, or Campbell frameworks. Triggers on any narrative structure, storytelling, pitch structure, StoryBrand, hero's journey, three-act structure, Freytag, Save the Cat, narrative arc, or "how should I structure this story/pitch/presentation" request.
legal-brief-writing
Use when writing legal briefs, motions, or any court filing; when analyzing judicial cognition and persuasion; when applying elite brief-writing techniques from Roberts, Clement, Kagan, Garner; or when structuring legal arguments for maximum persuasion. Also use for autistic/neurodivergent advocates who need to understand how their natural communication style maps to elite legal advocacy. Triggers on any legal writing, brief drafting, motion preparation, or legal argument structuring request.
journal-publishability-criteria
Use whenever a research paper, article or preprint is being written, revised, reviewed or published, and specifically before every publication of docs/paper.md. Covers what legitimate journals actually gate on, in order of gating — the editor's desk screen (scope, novelty, package problems), what reviewers judge (methodological soundness, claims the evidence can carry, statistical and qualitative reporting), EQUATOR reporting guidelines, the ICMJE authorship criteria, COPE's view of text recycling, the near-universal generative-AI policy (no AI author, disclosure, author responsibility), TOP 2025 transparency standards, how to verify a journal is legitimate, submitting without an institution, and a pre-submission checklist. Triggers on requests to evaluate, review, prepare or submit a paper, to judge publishability, to write a declarations or data-availability section, to disclose AI use, or to check a journal.