pedagogy-reading-research-and-zombie-ideas
Use when judging an education claim, a study or a piece of training: how to read education research critically including effect sizes, meta-analysis limits and why headline rankings mislead, the zombie ideas that keep returning — learning styles, the learning pyramid, digital natives, brain-based learning — and what teacher expertise actually consists of and how it develops.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-11-15
- Stars
- ★ 5
- Forks
- 3
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- pedagogy-reading-research-and-zombie-ideas
- description
- Use when judging an education claim, a study or a piece of training: how to read education research critically including effect sizes, meta-analysis limits and why headline rankings mislead, the zombie ideas that keep returning — learning styles, the learning pyramid, digital natives, brain-based learning — and what teacher expertise actually consists of and how it develops.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Pedagogy and Learning Science: Reading Education Research, Zombie Ideas, and Teacher Expertise
Part 4 of 5 of the Pedagogy and the Study of Learning and Teaching reference (plugin
pedagogy-and-the-study-of-learning), covering §22–§24. Sibling skills:pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects(§0–§7),pedagogy-explicit-instruction-worked-examples-and-feedback(§8–§13),pedagogy-subject-instruction-curriculum-and-classroom-practice(§14–§21),pedagogy-reference(§25–§30). Section numbers are shared across the set; a reference written as §N →skillpoints into that sibling skill.Currency: The cognitive science is stable and well-replicated. Two areas moved. See §25 →
pedagogy-referencefor AI in education, and post-pandemic achievement data.
⚠️ This field has an unusually wide gap between what is well-established and what is widely believed and practised. ⚠️ Some findings here are among the most robust in all of psychology; others in the same textbooks failed replication entirely; and a third group were never research findings at all — they were marketed.
Complements a psychology reference (§1's replication context) and a family/community reference (behaviour genetics, which constrains how much any intervention can do).
⚠️ GOTCHA boxes mark widely-taught ideas that the evidence contradicts.
⚠️ A disclosure about the political layer: ⚠️ education research is unusually ideologically loaded, because it touches how children are raised and how resources are allocated. ⚠️ Where a genuine scholarly dispute exists (§8 →
pedagogy-explicit-instruction-worked-examples-and-feedback, §14 →pedagogy-subject-instruction-curriculum-and-classroom-practice) I set out both positions; where the evidence is one-sided I say so and show the evidence.The three ideas that organize this document:
- ⚠️ Learning is a change in LONG-TERM MEMORY; performance during a lesson is not learning (§2 →
pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects, §7 →pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects). The two come apart routinely, and confusing them is the single most consequential error in teaching.- ⚠️ Working memory is tiny and prior knowledge is the great multiplier (§2 →
pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects, §3 →pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects). Almost every instructional design principle that works is managing that limit.- ⚠️ Things that FEEL like good learning usually aren't (§4 →
pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects, §7 →pedagogy-reliability-memory-cognitive-load-and-robust-effects). Fluency, familiarity and ease are systematically misleading — for students AND teachers.
§22. ⚠️ Reading Education Research
⚠️ The skill that protects you from most of §23.
⚠️ EFFECT SIZES ⚠️ Cohen's benchmarks (0.2/0.5/0.8) were never meant
for education. ⚠️ In education, ~0.1 is meaningful, 0.4 is large
for a well-run trial, ⚠️ and anything above 1.0 in a real school
trial should provoke suspicion, not excitement
⚠️ WHAT INFLATES EFFECT SIZES
⚠️ Researcher-made outcome measures aligned to the intervention
⚠️ Short duration and immediate post-tests
⚠️ Small samples · ⚠️ narrow-range populations
⚠️ Developer-delivered implementation
⚠️ Publication bias
⚠️ THE HATTIE CAUTION ⚠️ Visible Learning's league table of effect
sizes is enormously influential and has been substantively
criticized — for averaging incommensurable meta-analyses
("meta-meta-analysis"), for statistical errors identified by
several reviewers, and for the CLE metric. ⚠️ Use it to generate
hypotheses, NOT to rank interventions
⚠️ QUESTIONS TO ASK
Compared to WHAT? · Measured HOW? · For WHOM? · For HOW LONG? ·
⚠️ WHO delivered it? · ⚠️ WHO funded it? · ⚠️ Has an INDEPENDENT
team replicated it at scale?
⚠️ Better sources than a single study: ⚠️ the EEF Toolkit, the What Works Clearinghouse, Campbell and Cochrane reviews — and note that even these disagree, partly because they apply different inclusion standards.
§23. ⚠️ Zombie Ideas
⚠️ LEARNING STYLES ⚠️ The meshing hypothesis — that matching
instruction to a preferred style improves learning — has been
tested repeatedly and FAILS. ⚠️ People have preferences; matching
them does not help. ⚠️ Still believed by large majorities of
teachers in survey after survey
⚠️ THE LEARNING PYRAMID / "cone of experience" percentages
⚠️ Fabricated. The numbers have no traceable empirical source
⚠️ "WE ONLY USE 10% OF OUR BRAINS" ⚠️ False
⚠️ LEFT-BRAIN / RIGHT-BRAIN learners ⚠️ Not how lateralization works
⚠️ MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES ⚠️ Gardner's theory is not an empirically
validated model of ability, and ⚠️ Gardner himself has objected to
its conflation with learning styles
⚠️ BRAIN GYM ⚠️ No credible basis
⚠️ DIGITAL NATIVES ⚠️ Young people are not innately skilled with
technology; the research does not support a generational cognitive shift
⚠️ "TEACH SKILLS, NOT CONTENT" / content-free critical thinking
⚠️ Contradicted by §5 — critical thinking is largely domain-specific
⚠️ 70-20-10 ⚠️ No empirical origin (§20)
⚠️ "GOOGLE IT — memorization is obsolete" ⚠️ Contradicted by §2 and
§5: you cannot think with information you must look up
⚠️ The diagnostic that catches most of them: ⚠️ does the claim have a citable primary study, or only a diagram and a percentage? ⚠️ And does it flatter the listener?
§24. Teacher Expertise
⚠️ Teacher quality varies substantially and matters — ⚠️ but observable credentials
predict it poorly, which is why the policy problem is hard.
⚠️ PCK (pedagogical content knowledge): ⚠️ knowing the content is necessary and not
sufficient; the distinctive expertise is knowing how learners typically misunderstand THIS
topic and what representations work (§10 → pedagogy-explicit-instruction-worked-examples-and-feedback).
⚠️ Development: ⚠️ one-off professional development has poor evidence; sustained,
content-specific, coached programmes with follow-up do better. ⚠️ Instructional
coaching has among the better evidence bases in teacher development, and its constraint —
like tutoring (§18 → pedagogy-subject-instruction-curriculum-and-classroom-practice) — is cost.
⚠️ The expert blind spot (§10 → pedagogy-explicit-instruction-worked-examples-and-feedback) ⚠️ means experienced teachers can lose access to what
novices find hard, which is why student misconception data is so valuable.
04 同仓库更多 Skills
white-paper-writing
Use when writing white papers, technical reports, policy documents, thought leadership pieces, or any long-form authoritative document. Triggers on requests to write, structure, outline, or review white papers, technical reports, position papers, policy briefs, or evidence-driven arguments. Also use for B2B content marketing strategy, technical documentation requiring authority, academic-style reports, or any document that must educate while persuading. Use when someone asks "how should I structure this" for a long-form document.
prose-technical-mechanics
Use when editing or writing prose at a technical/mechanical level: choosing between Anglo-Saxon and Latinate diction, placing information in topic vs stress positions, writing periodic vs cumulative sentences, handling sentence rhythm, punctuation as logic, transitions, paragraph structure, or phonesthetics. Use when someone wants to understand WHY prose works or doesn't, not just surface-level style advice. Triggers on word choice, sentence structure, emphasis, rhythm, diction, or any deep writing mechanics question.
prose-mechanics
Use when writing, editing, or analyzing prose style; when trying to avoid generic AI-sounding writing; when applying specific prose styles such as journalistic, academic, narrative, KJV biblical, Hemingway plain, Latinate/Jamesian, Orwellian, Augustan, Victorian, Early Modern (Bacon, Browne, Milton), or free indirect discourse; or when coaching someone on writing voice and mechanics. Triggers on any request to improve, analyze, or write in a specific prose style, to fix "AI-sounding" writing, to make prose more vivid or concrete, to vary sentence rhythm, or to understand how a particular writer achieves their effects.
narrative-structure
Use when structuring stories, pitches, presentations, white papers, or any persuasive narrative; analyzing the hero's journey in fiction or non-fiction; applying StoryBrand for business communication; designing narrative arcs for thought leadership; or understanding Vogler, Snyder, Propp, or Campbell frameworks. Triggers on any narrative structure, storytelling, pitch structure, StoryBrand, hero's journey, three-act structure, Freytag, Save the Cat, narrative arc, or "how should I structure this story/pitch/presentation" request.
legal-brief-writing
Use when writing legal briefs, motions, or any court filing; when analyzing judicial cognition and persuasion; when applying elite brief-writing techniques from Roberts, Clement, Kagan, Garner; or when structuring legal arguments for maximum persuasion. Also use for autistic/neurodivergent advocates who need to understand how their natural communication style maps to elite legal advocacy. Triggers on any legal writing, brief drafting, motion preparation, or legal argument structuring request.
journal-publishability-criteria
Use whenever a research paper, article or preprint is being written, revised, reviewed or published, and specifically before every publication of docs/paper.md. Covers what legitimate journals actually gate on, in order of gating — the editor's desk screen (scope, novelty, package problems), what reviewers judge (methodological soundness, claims the evidence can carry, statistical and qualitative reporting), EQUATOR reporting guidelines, the ICMJE authorship criteria, COPE's view of text recycling, the near-universal generative-AI policy (no AI author, disclosure, author responsibility), TOP 2025 transparency standards, how to verify a journal is legitimate, submitting without an institution, and a pre-submission checklist. Triggers on requests to evaluate, review, prepare or submit a paper, to judge publishability, to write a declarations or data-availability section, to disclose AI use, or to check a journal.