AGENT SKILL

carval-market-analysis-and-timing

Use when researching the car market before buying or selling: the funnel procedure (macro to segment to model to local to live competition), definitions and failure modes of the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index, MMR, average transaction price, days' supply, incentives, loan APR/term/approval, negative-equity share; drivers (rates, new-car prices, off-lease supply, gas prices, tax-refund season, EV credit end, tariffs); segment divergence (EVs, hybrids, trucks, luxury); seasonality; regime tables with tactics for each side; cost-of-waiting math; and the October 2026 snapshot (Manheim 206.2, new ATP $50,089, used average $27,239, used EV listing $37,441, 5-year depreciation 41.8%).

License 许可
MIT
最近更新
2026-11-15
Stars
★ 5
Forks
3

01 前言 Front Matter

name
carval-market-analysis-and-timing
description
Use when researching the car market before buying or selling: the funnel procedure (macro to segment to model to local to live competition), definitions and failure modes of the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index, MMR, average transaction price, days' supply, incentives, loan APR/term/approval, negative-equity share; drivers (rates, new-car prices, off-lease supply, gas prices, tax-refund season, EV credit end, tariffs); segment divergence (EVs, hybrids, trucks, luxury); seasonality; regime tables with tactics for each side; cost-of-waiting math; and the October 2026 snapshot (Manheim 206.2, new ATP $50,089, used average $27,239, used EV listing $37,441, 5-year depreciation 41.8%).

03 SKILL.md 正文

Car Valuation and Market Research: Market Analysis, Drivers and Timing

Part 2 of 7 of the Car Valuation and Market Research reference (plugin car-valuation), covering §5–§9. Sibling skills: carval-concepts-methods-and-market-structure (§0–§4), carval-valuing-a-specific-vehicle (§10–§15), carval-buyer-playbook (§16–§20), carval-seller-playbook (§21–§25), carval-diligence-risk-and-ownership-economics (§26–§30), carval-reference (§31–§35).

Currency: Method is stable. The §9.3 numbers are an October 2026 snapshot: Manheim mid-September (published Sep 18), KBB August ATP (Sep 10), Edmunds Q2 negative equity (Jul 16), Cox used-EV data (Aug/Sep), iSeeCars (Mar 2026). They go stale within weeks; re-pull before using.

⚠️ Scope. Educational, not investment or financing advice. Nobody times used-car prices reliably; §9.4 explains what to do instead.

The three ideas:

  1. ⚠️ Wholesale leads, retail follows. Dealers buy at auction (Manheim) and price retail off that cost; when the Manheim index turns, listing prices typically follow with a lag of weeks to a couple of months. Watch wholesale and days' supply before sticker prices.
  2. ⚠️ "The used-car market" does not exist; segments diverge. In Aug 2026 Manheim reported compact cars and EVs up year over year while SUVs, pickups and midsize cars were down and the overall index was flat. Always value your segment (§8).
  3. ⚠️ The payment, not the price, clears this market. Rates, term length and loan approvals determine what buyers can afford; record negative equity and 70–84 month loans mean many buyers are payment-constrained (§7).

§5. The Market-Research Procedure (the funnel)

Step Question Where to look Output (one line each)
1. Macro Rates, credit availability, gas prices, consumer stress, tariffs/policy Fed/NY Fed, Experian/Edmunds loan data, EIA/AAA gas, news "Financing is [easier/tighter]; gas $X; stress indicators [ ]"
2. Wholesale Which way is the wholesale market moving? Cox/Manheim MUVVI (mid-month and monthly), MMR 3-year-old index, Cox wholesale days' supply "MUVVI [x] (±% MoM, ±% YoY)"
3. Retail/new New-car prices, incentives, inventory (substitutes and cap on used) KBB ATP report, Cox inventory "New ATP $X, incentives Y% of ATP, inventory Z"
4. Segment Body style/powertrain/price tier Cox segment tables, iSeeCars, Recurrent (EVs), Hagerty (classics) "My segment is [up/down] vs market"
5. Model & trim Depreciation, supply, redesign, recalls, reliability iSeeCars model depreciation, NHTSA recalls, owner forums "5-yr retention ~[x]%; redesign due [ ]"
6. Local Regional prices, days on lot, price cuts CarGurus/Autotrader/Cars.com filters (radius 100–250 mi), local dealer feeds "Local median asking $X; DOM Y; Z% cut"
7. Competition The 5–10 cars that actually compete with yours/target Live listings, sold where available "Best alternative costs $X all-in"
8. Diagnosis Regime and tactics (§9.1) Your notes One paragraph + 3 actions

Definition of "local": for common used cars, 100–250 miles is the relevant radius (buyers and online retailers move cars across state lines; the tax and fee differences can outweigh the price difference for distant cars). For rare/high-value cars, widen to national and use transport cost as the adjustment.


§6. Indicators: Definitions and How Each Lies

Indicator Definition Reads as ⚠️ Pitfalls
Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index (MUVVI) Monthly wholesale price index, adjusted for mix, mileage and seasonality; base Jan 1997 = 100 Direction of wholesale prices Not predictive for any individual car; adjusts for mix so it can differ from raw averages; mid-month reading is preliminary
Non-adjusted wholesale prices Raw average auction price What dealers actually paid Distorted by mix (age/mileage of cars sold)
MMR (Manheim Market Report) Wholesale value for a VIN-level vehicle What a dealer can pay Needs access; condition & region adjustments
MMR 3-Year-Old Index Wholesale price index for 3-year-old cars Early read on the "best-selling" age cohort Cohort-specific
Average transaction price (ATP), new Average price paid (KBB) New-car price level Mix-driven (more SUVs/trucks raise it); Aug 2026: $50,089
Incentives as % of ATP Average discount spend Pressure on new prices 6.5% in Aug 2026 (down from 7.2% a year earlier)
Average used sale price Average used transaction (KBB) Used price level Mix-driven; $27,239 (Aug 2026)
Days' supply Inventory ÷ daily sales Tightness (lower = tighter) Definitions differ for new/used and by source; KBB: 44 days used (Aug 2026)
Average listing price Dealer asking price Asking level Asking ≠ selling (§10)
Loan APR / term / amount Experian/Edmunds/Fed data Affordability Averages hide the subprime tail; Experian Q2 2026: new loan $43,610 at $765/mo over 69.5 months, used $27,852 at $542/mo over 67.9 months (⚠️ Experian via secondary summary)
Loan approval rate Share of applications approved Credit availability KBB (Aug 2026): lenders approved about three-quarters of applications ("easiest since 2015")
Negative-equity share % of trade-ins with loan > value Household stress; rollover risk Edmunds Q2 2026: 29.6% underwater, average $6,884, avg age 4.0 yrs
Delinquency Serious delinquency flow into 90+ days Credit stress NY Fed Q2 2026: 3.00% of balances (vs 2.93% a year earlier), balances $1.71T (⚠️ secondary)
EV/hybrid share and prices Cox EV Market Monitor, Recurrent Powertrain segment health EV values are policy- and gas-price-sensitive (§8)
Depreciation (5-year) % of MSRP lost at 5 years Resale expectation iSeeCars: 41.8% average (Mar 2025–Feb 2026), model dispersion huge

Rule: quote every indicator with source, definition, period and whether adjusted. Do not compare a raw average from one source to an adjusted index from another.


§7. What Moves Prices (and How to Read the Chain)

7.1 Wholesale → retail chain

  1. Supply entering wholesale: off-lease returns, rental fleet turn-ins, trade-ins from new-car buyers, repos. Model-year cohorts matter: very low 2021–2022 new-car production created a thin supply of 4–5-year-old cars later; weak 2023–2024 lease volumes can thin 2026–27 off-lease supply.
  2. Dealer buying cost (MMR) sets the retail ask. Retail asks = wholesale + reconditioning + margin (reported used-car gross margins of ~$2,000–$4,000 are cited by practitioner sources; verify).
  3. Retail demand is set by financing, new-car prices and incentives (substitution), gas prices (EVs/hybrids/small cars), tax-refund season and seasonality.

7.2 The financing channel

  • Payment math: at 6.35% over ~70 months, a $43,610 new loan is ~$747/month in this toolkit (Experian reports $765). Every 1 point of APR changes a 72-month payment by ~3%; term extensions lower payments but raise total interest (e.g., $31,500 over 48 months at 6.5% costs $4,357 in interest; 84 months at 8.5% costs $10,403).
  • Lender willingness (approval rates), term creep and rolled-in negative equity extend demand artificially; a credit tightening reduces demand quickly for the payment-constrained segment.
  • Auto-loan interest deduction (new, US-assembled only): small effect on aggregate demand; not a driver for used cars.

7.3 New-car substitution

New ATP above $50,000, incentives falling (6.5% of ATP), and sticker MSRP $51,852 push buyers toward used and toward cheaper segments (subcompact SUVs and compact cars gained share in 2026). Used prices are capped by the new-car alternative plus the payment gap.

7.4 Energy and policy

  • Gas prices (late July 2026 reported ≈ $4.10/gal, ~31% above a year earlier per Cox commentary via a secondary source) lift demand for compact cars, hybrids and EVs and weigh on large trucks/SUVs.
  • Federal EV credits ended Sept 30, 2025; new-EV sales fell (~−28% YoY in Q1 2026 per Cox via secondary), new-EV prices fell, while used EVs rose in value (see §8).
  • Tariffs: auto tariffs and parts costs feed new-car prices and, indirectly, used values; effects are contested and change with policy, so verify the current tariff regime before relying on any "tariff premium" claim (I did not independently verify 2026 tariff rates).

7.4A Seasonality and the calendar

  • Spring tax-refund surge: the Manheim index peaked at 215.3 in March 2026 (+6.2% YoY), then normalized through summer; by mid-September it stood at 206.2, 0.4% below Sept 2025 (first YoY decline of 2026) after a −1.0% monthly drop vs a typical −0.3% for September.
  • Model-year changeover (late summer–fall): outgoing-year new cars get discounted; a redesign of a model depresses the prior generation's values and raises uncertainty.
  • Month/quarter-end dealer quotas can matter for new-car deals; evidence is anecdotal and varies by dealer.
  • Weather/region: convertibles and 4WD/AWD have regional seasonality; snow-belt vs sun-belt rust and flood exposure change condition (§26).

§8. Segmentation: Never Average Across Segments

Segment 2026 read (Aug–Sep) Note
Overall wholesale Flat to slightly down YoY; fell 1% in the first half of September Cox: normalizing after spring bounce
Compact cars & EVs (wholesale) Up YoY in Aug, helped by high gas prices Cox mid-August
Midsize cars, SUVs, pickups (wholesale) Down YoY in Aug Cox mid-August; trucks/SUVs also carry the largest trade-in negative equity ($7k–$9k at Tundra/Sierra/Ram levels)
Used EVs Cox: average used-EV listing $37,441 (Aug), +8.2% YoY; wholesale used-EV values +12.4% YoY vs gas +1.1% (mid-July, via secondary); used-EV sales +20% YoY in June while new EV sales −28% ⚠️ Secondary sources conflict on direction early in 2026 (some showed −6% YoY in March). Segment is volatile and policy-/gas-price-driven; Recurrent: under-$40k EVs gained, $55k+ EVs fell ~3.3% in H1
Hybrids & trucks (retention) iSeeCars: best 5-yr value retention among segments Toyota dominates the hybrid list
EVs & luxury (retention) iSeeCars: 24 of the 25 worst 5-yr depreciators were EVs or luxury; EV depreciation barely improved in 2026 New-EV price cuts depress used values
Collector/classic Hagerty Market Rating near a ~15-year low; sub-$250k values broadly softening; blue-chip trophies selective Different regime, different data (§14.4)

Other cuts that matter: trim, drivetrain (AWD premiums by region), mileage bands (buyers filter at 60k/100k/150k; value cliffs sit just above those thresholds), model year vs generation (a pre-redesign car can be a bargain or a trap), color (neutral colors sell faster), options that buyers actually search for (driver-assist, towing, heated seats), and title status (brand discounts, §26).


§9. Regimes, Tactics and Timing Humility

9.1 Regime table (thresholds are heuristics; calibrate with local data)

Regime Used days' supply Wholesale trend Listings with cuts Seller tactic Buyer tactic
Hot <35 Rising >1%/mo Few Price at market; list fast; accept good offers Be pre-approved; decide quickly; verify condition anyway
Firm 35–45 Flat/up Moderate Price at comps; strong listing Shop several; negotiate OTD, not monthly payment
Balanced 45–55 Flat Moderate Price to comps; expect 3–5% negotiation on asks Compare 3+ OTD quotes; use days-on-lot
Soft 55–70 Falling Many Price sharply or take instant offer; don't wait Wait for stale listings; lower offers justified by comps
Falling >70 Falling >1.5%/mo Most Sell now; every month costs ~1–2% Hold cash; prices drop; beware catching knives

9.2 Leading indicators (check weekly while buying/selling)

  1. Manheim mid-month reading → 2) MMR 3-year-old index → 3) local days-on-lot and price-cut frequency for your model → 4) new-car incentives → 5) loan approval/APR changes → 6) gas price → 7) recall/redesign news for your model.

9.3 Snapshot: United States, October 2026 (re-pull before relying)

Metric Reading Source / date
Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index 206.2 mid-Sept (−1.0% MoM; −0.4% YoY, first YoY decline of 2026); Aug 208.2 (+0.4% YoY); Jul 210; Jun 212.9; Mar peak 215.3 (+6.2% YoY) Cox Automotive (Sep 18, 2026; Q2 release)
MMR 3-Year-Old Index −0.8% since the start of September (sharper than the same period last year; slightly above long-term average) Cox, Sep 18
Cox year-end outlook (set mid-year) MUVVI to finish 2026 ~+2% vs year-end 2025 ("normal seasonal pattern") Cox Q2 release ⚠️ may be revised
New-vehicle ATP $50,089 Aug (+0.5% MoM, +1.9% YoY); average MSRP $51,852; incentives 6.5% of ATP; new EV ATP $54,813 (−2.7% YoY); new-car inventory 2.68M units KBB/Cox, Sep 10
Used-vehicle average sale $27,239 Aug (highest since Dec 2022); dealer used supply 44 days KBB, Sep 2026
Loans (Q2 2026) New avg $43,610 / $765 / 69.5 mo; used $27,852 / $542 / 67.9 mo; approvals ~three-quarters of applications Experian (via secondary); KBB
Negative equity (Q2) 29.6% of trade-ins; avg $6,884; those buyers' new-loan payment $944 vs $777 average; projected interest $16,270 vs $9,811 Edmunds, Jul 16, 2026
Used EVs Cox avg listing $37,441 (Aug, +8.2% YoY); used EV share of Manheim units >4% record (July) Cox/Recurrent; ⚠️ partly secondary
5-yr depreciation 41.8% average (best: trucks/hybrids; worst: EVs/luxury) iSeeCars, Mar 2026
Collector cars Hagerty Market Rating near ~15-year low; condition-#3 values down ~0.5% book-to-book Hagerty (via trade press)

Reading it: wholesale values have given back the spring bounce and are now slightly below last year; new-car prices are rising slowly with incentives shrinking; loans are easier to get but heavily leveraged (record negative equity); segment divergence is large (EVs and compacts firm; trucks/SUVs soft). For buyers, the second half of the year is typically better than spring on used prices; for sellers, the spring window has passed and wholesale is drifting down, so waiting costs money (§9.4).

9.4 Timing humility (and the cost of waiting)

  • A depreciating asset rarely rewards waiting. If wholesale is falling ~1%/month and the car loses ~1–1.5%/month in value (age/mileage/market), selling 3 months later costs ~3–5% of value plus insurance, parking and opportunity cost. Use carval.retention_curve() for the age effect; use the Manheim trend for the market effect.
  • For buyers, waiting works only if you have a good alternative (current car is reliable), the market is falling, and financing/rates are not rising. A model-year changeover is the classic good time to buy the outgoing year new.
  • Avoid forecasting a "used-car crash" or "spike" as a decision rule; use scenario ranges (±5%) and buy/sell at a price that works at the low end.
  • Mileage clocks tick: each month of ownership adds ~1,000 miles; sell before crossing a mileage band (60k/100k).

§9A. Market Diagnosis Template (fill in, one paragraph)

"As of [date], the [segment] used-car market is [regime]. Manheim is [x] ([±% MoM, ±% YoY]); MMR for my car is $[x] (or a dealer-bought quote of $[x]). New ATP is $[x] with incentives [y]% and [z] days of used supply. Loans: APR [a]%, typical term [t] months; approvals [easy/tight]. Local asking median for my car is $[m] with [p]% price cuts and median days on lot [d]. Implication: [buyer/seller] tactics are [..]; my walk-away/floor is $[..]."

04 同仓库更多 Skills

the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

white-paper-writing

Use when writing white papers, technical reports, policy documents, thought leadership pieces, or any long-form authoritative document. Triggers on requests to write, structure, outline, or review white papers, technical reports, position papers, policy briefs, or evidence-driven arguments. Also use for B2B content marketing strategy, technical documentation requiring authority, academic-style reports, or any document that must educate while persuading. Use when someone asks "how should I structure this" for a long-form document.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

prose-technical-mechanics

Use when editing or writing prose at a technical/mechanical level: choosing between Anglo-Saxon and Latinate diction, placing information in topic vs stress positions, writing periodic vs cumulative sentences, handling sentence rhythm, punctuation as logic, transitions, paragraph structure, or phonesthetics. Use when someone wants to understand WHY prose works or doesn't, not just surface-level style advice. Triggers on word choice, sentence structure, emphasis, rhythm, diction, or any deep writing mechanics question.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

prose-mechanics

Use when writing, editing, or analyzing prose style; when trying to avoid generic AI-sounding writing; when applying specific prose styles such as journalistic, academic, narrative, KJV biblical, Hemingway plain, Latinate/Jamesian, Orwellian, Augustan, Victorian, Early Modern (Bacon, Browne, Milton), or free indirect discourse; or when coaching someone on writing voice and mechanics. Triggers on any request to improve, analyze, or write in a specific prose style, to fix "AI-sounding" writing, to make prose more vivid or concrete, to vary sentence rhythm, or to understand how a particular writer achieves their effects.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

narrative-structure

Use when structuring stories, pitches, presentations, white papers, or any persuasive narrative; analyzing the hero's journey in fiction or non-fiction; applying StoryBrand for business communication; designing narrative arcs for thought leadership; or understanding Vogler, Snyder, Propp, or Campbell frameworks. Triggers on any narrative structure, storytelling, pitch structure, StoryBrand, hero's journey, three-act structure, Freytag, Save the Cat, narrative arc, or "how should I structure this story/pitch/presentation" request.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

legal-brief-writing

Use when writing legal briefs, motions, or any court filing; when analyzing judicial cognition and persuasion; when applying elite brief-writing techniques from Roberts, Clement, Kagan, Garner; or when structuring legal arguments for maximum persuasion. Also use for autistic/neurodivergent advocates who need to understand how their natural communication style maps to elite legal advocacy. Triggers on any legal writing, brief drafting, motion preparation, or legal argument structuring request.

★ 5
the-vibey-project
the-vibey-project/vibey

journal-publishability-criteria

Use whenever a research paper, article or preprint is being written, revised, reviewed or published, and specifically before every publication of docs/paper.md. Covers what legitimate journals actually gate on, in order of gating — the editor's desk screen (scope, novelty, package problems), what reviewers judge (methodological soundness, claims the evidence can carry, statistical and qualitative reporting), EQUATOR reporting guidelines, the ICMJE authorship criteria, COPE's view of text recycling, the near-universal generative-AI policy (no AI author, disclosure, author responsibility), TOP 2025 transparency standards, how to verify a journal is legitimate, submitting without an institution, and a pre-submission checklist. Triggers on requests to evaluate, review, prepare or submit a paper, to judge publishability, to write a declarations or data-availability section, to disclose AI use, or to check a journal.

★ 5