adversarial-debate
Run a structured advocate-vs-critic debate on a bounded proposal or decision.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-11-07
- Stars
- ★ 1
- Forks
- 0
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- adversarial-debate
- description
- Run a structured advocate-vs-critic debate on a bounded proposal or decision.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Adversarial Debate
Outcome
Force explicit advocate and critic perspectives on a single bounded proposal or decision before committing. Prevents groupthink and shallow agreement in single-agent or sequential-pass workflows.
When to trigger
- before an irreversible architecture decision;
- when reviewers disagree;
- when a proposal has no natural opposition but the stakes are high;
- when using
/sudoto switch personas and a structured debate is needed.
Procedure
- Define the proposal or decision under debate in one paragraph.
- Advocate pass: argue why the proposal is correct, safe, and the best available option. Surface evidence supporting the proposal.
- Critic pass: argue why the proposal is wrong, risky, or incomplete. Surface evidence against the proposal. Identify missing alternatives.
- Synthesis: the lead agent weighs both passes, identifies the strongest points from each, and records the decision with confidence and conditions.
- Record the debate summary in
HANDOFF.toonor an ADR if the decision is durable.
Using with /sudo
/sudo architect advocate for the proposed persistence boundary
/sudo tech-lead criticise the proposed persistence boundary
Or run both passes as the same agent using sequential /sudo calls. Note
that sequential passes by the same agent are not equivalent to independent
review — record this limitation.
Patterns
| Pattern | Advocate | Critic |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | argues for the boundary, dependency direction, or integration | argues for simplicity, alternative boundaries, or coupling risk |
| Build vs buy | argues for building in-house | argues for buying or reusing |
| Scope | argues for including a feature | argues for deferring or removing |
| Technology | argues for a tool or framework | argues against it or for alternatives |
Do not
- Use adversarial debate for trivial mechanical changes.
- Let the critic pass become a veto — the lead agent owns the synthesis.
- Skip recording the debate when the decision is irreversible or durable.
- Pretend sequential passes constitute independent review.
04 同仓库更多 Skills
agentic-template
Start or continue work in this repository using the canonical AGENTS.md contract and repository skill catalog.
wiki-tidy
Reconcile the wiki against the knowledge graph, specs and code; prune stale, keep links resolving.
update-handoff
Update HANDOFF.toon with current semantic work state.
test-first
Drive meaningful behaviour changes with the smallest useful failing test.
test-change
Select and run tests that prove a change at suitable fidelity.
specify
Create proportional OpenSpec-shaped structured change proposals for meaningful changes.