AGENT SKILL

adversarial-debate

Run a structured advocate-vs-critic debate on a bounded proposal or decision.

License 许可
MIT
最近更新
2026-11-07
Stars
★ 1
Forks
0

01 前言 Front Matter

name
adversarial-debate
description
Run a structured advocate-vs-critic debate on a bounded proposal or decision.

03 SKILL.md 正文

Adversarial Debate

Outcome

Force explicit advocate and critic perspectives on a single bounded proposal or decision before committing. Prevents groupthink and shallow agreement in single-agent or sequential-pass workflows.

When to trigger

  • before an irreversible architecture decision;
  • when reviewers disagree;
  • when a proposal has no natural opposition but the stakes are high;
  • when using /sudo to switch personas and a structured debate is needed.

Procedure

  1. Define the proposal or decision under debate in one paragraph.
  2. Advocate pass: argue why the proposal is correct, safe, and the best available option. Surface evidence supporting the proposal.
  3. Critic pass: argue why the proposal is wrong, risky, or incomplete. Surface evidence against the proposal. Identify missing alternatives.
  4. Synthesis: the lead agent weighs both passes, identifies the strongest points from each, and records the decision with confidence and conditions.
  5. Record the debate summary in HANDOFF.toon or an ADR if the decision is durable.

Using with /sudo

/sudo architect advocate for the proposed persistence boundary
/sudo tech-lead criticise the proposed persistence boundary

Or run both passes as the same agent using sequential /sudo calls. Note that sequential passes by the same agent are not equivalent to independent review — record this limitation.

Patterns

Pattern Advocate Critic
Architecture argues for the boundary, dependency direction, or integration argues for simplicity, alternative boundaries, or coupling risk
Build vs buy argues for building in-house argues for buying or reusing
Scope argues for including a feature argues for deferring or removing
Technology argues for a tool or framework argues against it or for alternatives

Do not

  • Use adversarial debate for trivial mechanical changes.
  • Let the critic pass become a veto — the lead agent owns the synthesis.
  • Skip recording the debate when the decision is irreversible or durable.
  • Pretend sequential passes constitute independent review.

04 同仓库更多 Skills