decision-making
Runs a structured decision process for high-stakes choices - reversibility classification, weighted decision matrices, expected value with explicit probabilities, pre-mortems, second-order thinking, and 10/10/10 - and produces a documented recommendation plus a decision-journal entry. Use when someone asks "should I take this job or stay", "how do I decide between these two paths", "I keep going back and forth on a big decision", or "help me think through whether to relocate". Do NOT use for evaluating a specific large purchase like a house, car, or equipment - use big-purchase-decision instead.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-10-05
- Stars
- ★ 1
- Forks
- 0
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- decision-making
- metadata
- { "title": "Decision Making" }
- description
- Runs a structured decision process for high-stakes choices - reversibility classification, weighted decision matrices, expected value with explicit probabilities, pre-mortems, second-order thinking, and 10/10/10 - and produces a documented recommendation plus a decision-journal entry. Use when someone asks "should I take this job or stay", "how do I decide between these two paths", "I keep going back and forth on a big decision", or "help me think through whether to relocate". Do NOT use for evaluating a specific large purchase like a house, car, or equipment - use big-purchase-decision instead.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Decision Making
Most bad decisions are not caused by bad reasoning - they are caused by deciding the wrong question, rationalizing a pre-chosen favorite, or spending a week of analysis on a choice that could be undone in an afternoon. This process matches the depth of analysis to the stakes, forces criteria to be written before options are scored, and leaves a journal entry so judgment can be calibrated later.
Operating procedure
Order matters: classification comes first because it decides whether the rest of the process runs at all, and criteria must be locked before any option is scored - scoring first invites rationalizing a favorite.
Step 1: Gather inputs
Collect before analyzing. Label any estimate the user cannot source as a guess.
- The decision, stated in one sentence with a deadline. Default deadline if none exists: set one now - endless analysis is itself a costly choice.
- The real options on the table. Push for at least three; a binary framing usually hides a third option (negotiate, delay, pilot, partial commitment).
- What happens if the user does nothing (the status quo is always an option and often the silently chosen one).
- Constraints that are truly fixed vs. merely assumed.
- The user's emotional state (tired, rushed, angry, infatuated with one option) - record it; it belongs in the journal entry.
Step 2: Classify reversibility
- Two-way door (reversible, low stakes): decide fast and move on. Rule of thumb: if undoing the choice costs less than a day of effort, spend minutes, not days. Decide with roughly 70% of the information you wish you had - waiting for 90% means you were slow.
- One-way door (irreversible or high stakes - quitting a job, relocating, marriage, shutting down a product): run Steps 3-8 in full.
Say which classification applies and why before proceeding.
Step 3: Frame the real question
State precisely what is being decided, what problem it solves, and whether that is the right problem. Surface hidden assumptions ("this assumes the promotion won't come through - is that confirmed?").
Step 4: Define weighted criteria, then score
List what matters and assign weights summing to 100% before evaluating any option. Separate must-haves (pass/fail gates) from weighted nice-to-haves. Then score each option 1-5 per criterion and compute weighted totals.
Worked example - stay at current employer vs. join a Series B startup:
Criterion Weight Stay Startup
Career growth 30% 2 5
Compensation 25% 4 3
Role/team fit 20% 3 4
Stability 15% 5 2
Location/lifestyle 10% 4 4
Weighted total 3.35 3.75
Stay: (0.30×2)+(0.25×4)+(0.20×3)+(0.15×5)+(0.10×4) = 3.35. Startup: 3.75. A gap under ~0.3 is a tie - the matrix says the decision hinges on the weights, so stress-test them. Here the 0.40 gap favors the startup, but only because growth was weighted 30%; if the user quietly believes stability matters most, the weights were dishonest and must be redone.
Step 5: Put explicit probabilities on uncertain payoffs
Where an option's value depends on uncertain outcomes, compute expected value with stated probabilities instead of vibes. Example for the startup's equity over 4 years: 60% chance worth $0, 30% chance worth $40,000, 10% chance worth $400,000. EV = 0.6×0 + 0.3×40,000 + 0.1×400,000 = $52,000, about $13,000/year - compare that against the salary gap, not the fantasy outcome. Writing the probabilities down also exposes overconfidence: if the user cannot defend the 10%, lower it.
Step 6: Second-order thinking and 10/10/10
- Trace consequences past the first order: the obvious result, then the result of that result, then longer-term systemic effects. Many bad decisions look good only at first order.
- Run 10/10/10: how will this choice feel in 10 minutes, 10 months, and 10 years? It separates transient discomfort (a hard conversation) from durable regret (a decade in the wrong career).
Step 7: Pre-mortem and bias sweep
Assume it is one year later and the decision failed badly. Write the story of why: warning signs, what was overlooked. Mitigate the top 2-3 risks before committing. Then check the four classic biases explicitly:
- Confirmation: name one piece of disconfirming evidence actively sought.
- Sunk cost: strike any reasoning that cites past spend; only future value counts.
- Anchoring: question whoever supplied the first number or framing.
- Overconfidence: attach an honest confidence percentage to the expected outcome.
Finish with inversion: ask "what would guarantee failure?" and confirm the chosen option avoids those things.
Step 8: Decide, commit, and journal
Make the call by the deadline and record a decision-journal entry:
DECISION JOURNAL - [FILL: date]
Decision: [FILL: one sentence]
Options considered: [FILL]
Choice and why: [FILL: top 3 reasons]
Expected outcome: [FILL] - confidence: [FILL]%
Key assumptions: [FILL: the 2-3 that, if wrong, flip the decision]
State of mind: [FILL: tired / rushed / calm / excited]
Review date: [FILL: 6-12 months out]
Review entries months later to separate good decisions from lucky outcomes.
Deliverable
Produce a one-page decision brief containing: the reversibility classification, the framed question, the weighted criteria matrix with scores, expected-value math for any probabilistic payoff, the second-order/10-10-10 read, the pre-mortem top risks with mitigations, a clear recommendation, and a filled decision-journal entry.
Do NOT
- Do not run the full process on a two-way door - over-analysis of reversible choices is its own failure mode.
- Do not score options before weights are locked; that is how a favorite gets rationalized.
- Do not present a weighted total under a 0.3 gap as a verdict; call it a tie and interrogate the weights.
- Do not let equity, lottery-style upside, or "best case" numbers into the comparison without explicit probabilities attached.
- Do not skip the journal entry; without it there is no way to calibrate judgment later.
Quality bar
- The reversibility classification is stated and justified before any analysis.
- Criteria and weights were written before options were scored.
- Every uncertain payoff carries an explicit probability the user agreed to.
- The pre-mortem names at least two concrete failure modes with mitigations.
- The journal entry is filled in, including confidence and state of mind, with a review date set.
04 同仓库更多 Skills
study-system
Converts a syllabus or topic list into an evidence-based study plan - material atomized into testable units, a spaced-repetition flashcard schedule with expanding intervals, active recall and Feynman-technique prompts instead of rereading, interleaved weekly sessions, and a practice-testing cadence with an error log. Use when someone says "help me study for this exam", "build me a study schedule", "I keep rereading and forgetting everything", or wants to learn a curriculum efficiently. Do NOT use for acquiring a spoken language specifically - use language-learning instead - or for building everyday habits - use habit-builder instead.
stress-management
Builds a personalized one-page stress toolkit - mapped triggers, three rehearsed in-the-moment interventions, a recovery menu, and prevention habits - from a week of trigger tracking. Use when someone says "I'm constantly stressed", "I can't switch off after work", "help me deal with anxiety before meetings", or "I keep snapping at people". General wellness education, not medical or mental-health treatment. Do NOT use when the primary complaint is poor sleep - use sleep-optimizer instead; for building a single recurring habit, use habit-builder; for broader life direction and goals, use life-coach.
sleep-optimizer
Builds a personalized sleep protocol - a fixed wake time held within 30 minutes daily, a chronotype-aligned sleep window, a light-exposure plan, environment settings, evening input rules, and a scripted wind-down routine - from a baseline assessment. Use when someone says "I can't fall asleep", "I wake up at 3am every night", "fix my sleep schedule", or "I'm exhausted no matter how long I sleep". General wellness education, not medical advice - snoring with gasping, suspected apnea, or chronic insomnia route to a physician or sleep specialist. Do NOT use when racing thoughts and daytime stress are the primary complaint - use stress-management instead; for the broader multi-pillar health routine, use longevity-protocol.
second-brain
Sets up a PARA-based second brain in any notes app (Notion, Obsidian, Apple Notes, Logseq) - Projects, Areas, Resources, Archives buckets, a frictionless universal capture inbox, weekly organizing, wiki-link and map-of-content linking, progressive summarization for recall, and maintenance rituals. Use when someone says "help me set up a second brain", "my notes are a mess and I can never find anything", "how do I organize Obsidian with PARA", or captures ideas but never uses them. Do NOT use for designing the underlying Notion database properties and relations - use notion-database instead - or for a task-management workflow - use gtd-system instead.
journal-framework
Designs a sustainable daily journaling practice - morning pages, gratitude, intention setting, evening reflection, and weekly review - matched to the user's goal, with copy-paste templates and a rotating prompt library. Use when someone asks "help me start journaling", "give me journal prompts", "I keep abandoning my journal", or "build me a morning pages routine". Do NOT use for building a general habit or streak system - use habit-builder instead; do NOT use for organizing notes and knowledge into a retrieval system - use second-brain instead; for structured end-of-week planning reviews, see weekly-review.
habit-builder
Turns a vague intention into a one-page habit plan - a specific implementation intention, a habit-stack anchor sentence, cue-craving-routine-reward loop mapping, environment design, a never-miss-twice tracking method, and weekly review questions. Use when someone says "help me build a habit", "I want to exercise more but can't stick with it", "why do my habits keep failing", or wants to break a bad habit by removing its cues. Do NOT use for goal-setting with an accountability structure - use goals-accountability instead; for a full training program, use fitness-program.