steuer-subsumption
Performs tax subsumption: maps a concrete fact pattern (Sachverhalt) to the applicable tax norm and states the tax consequence (Tatbestand → Steuerfolge). Covers DE (EStG, KStG, UStG, GewStG, AO, ErbStG, GrEStG) and AT (EStG, KStG, UStG, BAO). Steps: extract facts → identify applicable tax norms → subsume → state the tax consequence with amounts where computable → cite exact §§ and controlling BFH/BFG case law from the brain. NEVER issues binding tax advice; flags every conclusion as AI-assisted analysis requiring tax-advisor review.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-07-09
- Stars
- ★ 0
- Forks
- 0
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- steuer-subsumption
- tools
- [ "search", "query", "think", "get_page", "add_timeline_entry" ]
- version
- 1.0.0
- mutating
- true
- priority
- 70
- triggers
- [ "steuerlich subsumieren", "Steuerfolge", "steuerliche Einordnung", "welche Steuer fällt an", "ist das steuerpflichtig", "ist das absetzbar", "Betriebsausgabe oder nicht", "Werbungskosten prüfen", "steuerbar oder steuerfrei", "Tatbestand Steuer", "tax subsumption", "is this taxable", "is this deductible", "tax treatment of" ]
- description
- Performs tax subsumption: maps a concrete fact pattern (Sachverhalt) to the applicable tax norm and states the tax consequence (Tatbestand → Steuerfolge). Covers DE (EStG, KStG, UStG, GewStG, AO, ErbStG, GrEStG) and AT (EStG, KStG, UStG, BAO). Steps: extract facts → identify applicable tax norms → subsume → state the tax consequence with amounts where computable → cite exact §§ and controlling BFH/BFG case law from the brain. NEVER issues binding tax advice; flags every conclusion as AI-assisted analysis requiring tax-advisor review.
03 SKILL.md 正文
Steuer-Subsumption Skill
Warning: AI-generated tax analysis. All conclusions require review by a tax advisor (Steuerberater/in) before use. Output is marked accordingly. Convention: See conventions/quality.md. Every § reference cites the exact norm. Chains with: tax-ruling-lookup for Bescheid analysis, umsatzsteuer-check for VAT specifics.
Contract
This skill guarantees:
- Every applicable tax norm is cited with § number and statute acronym (EStG, UStG, KStG, AO, …).
- The subsumption follows Gutachtenstil (issue → norm → subsumption → result).
- Controlling BFH/BFG/EuGH decisions are cited where found in the brain.
- Computable amounts are shown with the calculation path, never as a binding figure.
- The output is marked as tax-advisor-review-required and carries the EU AI Act notice.
Trigger Conditions
Use this skill when the user presents a fact pattern and asks for the tax classification, the applicable tax norm, deductibility, or the tax consequence. Do NOT use for pure bookkeeping exports (→ datev-export) or for analyzing an existing tax notice (→ tax-ruling-lookup).
Protocol
Step 1 — Extract the Fact Pattern
- Taxpayer: natural person / partnership (Mitunternehmerschaft) / corporation (KapG)?
- Transaction: what happened, when, for how much, with whom?
- Tax(es) in scope: income (ESt/KSt), trade (GewSt), VAT (USt), transfer (GrESt), inheritance/gift (ErbSt/SchenkSt)?
- Jurisdiction & period: DE / AT, assessment year (Veranlagungszeitraum).
Step 2 — Norm Search
gbrain search "<key facts> § Tatbestand" --mode balanced --source tax-corpus
gbrain search "<key facts> BFH Urteil" --source tax-corpus
Retrieve the exact § text and any BFH/BFG leading decision from the brain.
Step 3 — Subsumption (Gutachtenstil)
For each candidate norm: list its Tatbestandsmerkmale, map each to the fact, mark erfüllt / nicht erfüllt, then state the Steuerfolge with the computation path.
Step 4 — File in Brain
gbrain put_page \
--slug "tax/analyses/subsumption-[slug]-[date]" \
--type "document" \
--metadata '{"document_type":"tax_analysis","requires_review":true,"ai_generated":true}'
Jurisdiction Quick Reference
| Jurisdiction | Income | Corporate | VAT | Trade | Transfer / Inheritance | Procedure |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DE | EStG | KStG | UStG | GewStG | GrEStG, ErbStG | AO, FGO |
| AT | EStG | KStG | UStG | — (KommSt) | GrEStG, ErbSt aufgehoben | BAO |
| EU | — | — | MwStSystRL | — | — | EuGH |
Output Format
## Steuerliche Analyse — [Datum] — Vorläufig, kein Mandatsverhältnis
### I. Sachverhalt
[3–5 Sätze]
### II. Anwendbare Normen
- § [X] [Gesetz]: [Tatbestand] [Quelle: brain page]
- § [Y] [Gesetz]: [Rechtsfolge] [Quelle]
### III. Subsumption
**Zu § [X]:** Merkmal 1 ([Wortlaut]): [Umstand] → [erfüllt/nicht erfüllt] …
**Ergebnis zu § [X]:** [Steuerfolge], weil […].
### IV. Berechnung (sofern möglich)
[Bemessungsgrundlage → Steuersatz → Betrag, mit Rechenweg; ausdrücklich unverbindlich]
### V. Leitentscheidungen
- [Az.]: [Leitsatz] (falls im Brain gefunden)
### VI. Gesamtergebnis & Empfehlungen
- [ ] Steuerberatliche Überprüfung erforderlich
- [ ] Fehlende Informationen: […]
- [ ] Nächste Schritte: […]
---
⚠️ KI-generiert · zu prüfen — ersetzt keine steuerliche Beratung (§ 2 StBerG).
Erstellt: [Datum] | Skill: steuer-subsumption v1.0.0
Anti-Patterns
- ❌ Presenting a computed tax figure as binding. Always: "orientation, verify with advisor."
- ❌ Subsuming without citing the exact §. If the corpus lacks the norm, say so.
- ❌ Mixing DE and AT norms silently. Default DE; switch only when jurisdiction is stated.
- ❌ Ignoring § 42 AO (Gestaltungsmissbrauch) when the fact pattern is structuring-driven → route to steuer-gestaltung.
- ❌ Omitting the AI / advisor-review notice.
Error Handling
- No relevant norm in brain → say so explicitly, recommend advisor consultation.
- Incomplete facts → list exactly what is missing before subsuming.
- Multiple norms apply → subsume under each separately.
04 同仓库更多 Skills
query-helper
暂无简介
broken
暂无简介
brain-ops
Read, enrich, and write brain pages with source attribution.
signal-detector
Always-on ambient signal capture for the OpenClaw reference fixture.
query
Look up brain pages in the OpenClaw reference fixture.
context-now
ALWAYS-ON time-sensitivity discipline for the OpenClaw reference fixture.