harmonization-over-accretion
Reusable rebuttal pattern for "let's import all N items from competitor X" temptations. Explains why connectome-graph brains lose precision (not gain capability) from bulk imports. Use anytime an agent or operator considers mass-adopting skills, agents, commands, or hooks from a peer repo.
- License 许可
- MIT
- 最近更新
- 2026-11-14
- Stars
- ★ 18
- Forks
- 6
01 前言 Front Matter
- name
- harmonization-over-accretion
- metadata
- { "type": "pattern-reference", "origin": "session-learn-extractor — 2026-05-28 ECC 249-skills decision; promoted from skills/learned/ same day" }
- description
- Reusable rebuttal pattern for "let's import all N items from competitor X" temptations. Explains why connectome-graph brains lose precision (not gain capability) from bulk imports. Use anytime an agent or operator considers mass-adopting skills, agents, commands, or hooks from a peer repo.
02 资源文件 1
- 参考文档skill.json419 B
03 SKILL.md 正文
Harmonization Over Accretion
When this fires
Any of these prompts:
- "X has N skills/agents/commands, why don't we add them all?"
- "Let's bulk-import the <competitor> catalog"
- "More neurons = smarter brain, right?"
- "We should at least mirror their skill count"
This skill is the canonical reply. It is NOT a no-by-reflex — it is a structured five-point cost analysis that lets you say "no" with evidence, or "yes selectively" with criteria.
The five costs of bulk-import (in any TF-IDF / cosine-similarity brain)
- Activation dilution — top-K retrieval returns lower per-match signal. The brain hesitates on which skill to load.
- Wrong-bucket activation — irrelevant skills share enough vocabulary (auth, deploy, security, test) to occasionally win retrieval. A Python deploy task could load
perl-security. - Silent coverage duplication — the connectome knows closest, not best. Two good skills for the same job = worse than one.
- Maintenance debt × N — every skill ages. Bulk-import = bulk-staling. Each staled skill is a regression-in-waiting.
- Forgetting-curve broken — biological brains prune unused synapses. Feature, not bug. A hoarder brain is not an expert.
Vanity metric mapping
| Cheap public metric | What it actually signals |
|---|---|
249 skills |
The team imported broadly. Says nothing about per-task precision. |
182K stars |
The repo was promoted (or inflated). Says nothing about depth of use. |
170+ contributors |
Mostly typo-PRs and badge-PRs unless the active-author ratio (last 30d / total) is >5%. |
Real metric to optimize: per-task activation precision. When a real task arrives, does the brain return the 3 right skills, or 30 with-noise? Bulk-import always pushes the second.
The right alternative — passive cherry-pick via daily watch
repo-watch— daily monitor of a curated 7-repo watchlist (cap is hard at 7 per Trend Researcher rule). Logs HIGH-SIGNAL diffs toknowledge/repo-watch/triggers/<repo>-<sha>.trigger./repo-deep-learn— manual evaluation of a single trigger using the harmonization model: each pattern earns ADD / MERGE-WITH:<skill> / REPLACE:<skill> / EXTEND:<skill> / SKIP, with similarity gate (TF-IDF cosine) + beat-factor (default 2× incumbent maturity proxy) required for REPLACE.github-trending-curation— autonomous breadth sibling. Same harmonization model. Cap ≤3 auto-promotes per day.
Cadence: weeks-to-months for each peer-brain pattern that actually graduates. By design.
Reusable analogy bank
- "Una orquesta de 60 músicos top toca mejor Mahler que una banda escolar de 600."
- "More books on the shelf ≠ smarter. More books read and indexed = smarter."
- "A search engine with 10× more pages isn't 10× better. It's 10× harder to rank."
See also
- [[github-trending-curation]] — the autonomous breadth half of harmonization
- [[repo-watch]] — the targeted daily-watch half
- [[repo-deep-learn]] — the manual one-at-a-time evaluator
- [[feedback-more-skills-not-smarter]] — memory version of this stance
- [[feedback-professional-not-famous]] — adjacent operator stance: substance > visibility
04 同仓库更多 Skills
yeet
Use only when the user explicitly asks to stage, commit, push, and open a GitHub pull request in one flow using the GitHub CLI (`gh`).
wrangler
Cloudflare Workers CLI for deploying, developing, and managing Workers, KV, R2, D1, Vectorize, Hyperdrive, Workers AI, Containers, Queues, Workflows, Pipelines, and Secrets Store. Load before running wrangler commands to ensure correct syntax and best practices. Biases towards retrieval from Cloudflare docs over pre-trained knowledge.
workspace-skill-discovery
Discover and include ALL skills across the workspace — not just global ones. Use at the start of every session or when the user asks about available skills. Ensures project-level skills (under .claude/skills/ or skills/ in any repo) are never missed.
workers-best-practices
Reviews and authors Cloudflare Workers code against production best practices. Load when writing new Workers, reviewing Worker code, configuring wrangler.jsonc, or checking for common Workers anti-patterns (streaming, floating promises, global state, secrets, bindings, observability). Biases towards retrieval from Cloudflare docs over pre-trained knowledge.
winui-app
Create, build and design WinUI 3 desktop apps with C# and the Windows App SDK following Microsoft's official guidance and CommunityToolkit. Covers XAML, navigation, theming, accessibility and deployment.
windows-brain-script-portability
Scripts in ~/.claude/scripts/ that run on a Windows brain: use the python3.cmd shim and not bare python3, and reconfigure stdout to UTF-8 if you print symbols. Use it when writing a brain script or triaging a Windows-only crash.