issue-root-resolution

Activation Contract

Load when auditing a defect backlog for shared root causes, proposing a fix for an issue cluster, or closing issues as resolved/outdated. Complements rdd-defect-workflow (single-defect flow) — this skill governs the cluster-level method.

Hard Rules

• Read full bodies and comments, never titles. Classify against the actual code or PR diff, not descriptions of it.
• Verify every "fixed" or "broken" claim against current origin/main the day you act. Compare report dates to fix merge dates: a repro filed before the fix landed is evidence about old builds, not current code.
• Cluster defects by causal root, not surface. Each root gets a measured row in the meta-issue (#2471 style): issues attached, fix shape, state.
• Before proposing any fix, produce a read-only mechanism map: one file:line anchor per claim, mechanism explained as implemented today. Report claim-vs-code mismatches explicitly; never force evidence to fit the hypothesis. Let the map shrink the proposal.
• Rank solutions by what they DELETE: (1) removes a mechanism so the class becomes impossible, (2) static guard-ratchet making reintroduction a test failure, (3) localized predicate fix behind a failing repro test. New surface (verbs, flags, mechanisms) is last resort — defer until re-verified evidence demands it.
• Extract maintainer choices as named D-items with recommended defaults. A maintainer condition recorded in an issue thread outranks any plan table, including yours.
• Close only with evidence, one rule per closure: (A) fixed on main, cite commit AND proving test; (B) superseded by recorded maintainer decision; (C) surface no longer exists; (D) duplicate of a fixed issue. Comment before closing: what resolved it, verified today, reopen invitation. When in doubt, do not close — list as borderline.
• Clean break, never compatibility. When a format or identity changes, bump its versioned tag as a REPLACEMENT: old records become outdated and fail closed with an actionable refusal naming the rerun. Never write dual recognition, legacy fallbacks, or compat shims; that residue is what the deletion criterion exists to prevent. Stored bytes are never rewritten and stay readable for forensics, but carry no gate or lifecycle validity.
• Implementation follows the waves recipe: repro as failing test first, byte-stable goldens as defect signal, independently revertible slices, one writer per slice.
• A universal guard's verification matrix is go test ./... at the repository root, never a curated package list. A guard that forbids a shape breaks every fixture that relied on it, including in packages the change never touched.
• One worktree per writer, always, including the orchestrator. Before editing inline, check whether a delegated worker holds that path; if so, create a separate worktree rather than reusing it.
• Audit every worker report yourself: re-run its key verification, decoy-test any new guard, spot-check its diffs. A self-report is a claim, not evidence.

Decision Gates

Condition	Action
Issue's failure mechanism absent from current main	Re-verify on latest build; close by rule A/C or mark stale — never fix ghost code.
Fix would add a mechanism, flag, or verb	Defer with written reason; re-rank for a deletion-shaped alternative first.
Map contradicts the issue or your hypothesis	The map wins. Revise the plan and correct the public record (meta-issue) before coding.
Blocker's fix lives in an unmerged PR	Leave open; it closes on merge or by its own thread condition.
Closure evidence incomplete	Borderline list, not closure.

Execution Steps

1. Measure: read the cluster fully; partition by root; record counts in the meta-issue.
2. Classify each issue against the real diff/code; separate closes-via-X, improved-not-closed, unrelated, blocker.
3. Map mechanisms read-only with anchors; flag mismatches.
4. Rank fixes deletion-first; name D-items; get maintainer answers.
5. Implement in slices (issue-first: every PR links a status:approved issue), audit each worker report.
6. Hygiene pass: evidence-gated closures, stale-repro re-verification requests, meta-issue update with what changed and why.

Edge Cases

• An issue filed before a fix merged is evidence about old builds, not a claim against current main.
• When the mechanism map contradicts the hypothesis, the map wins and the plan must be revised first.
• A fix that adds a new mechanism, flag, or verb is deferred until a deletion-shaped alternative is ruled out.

Output Contract

Per pass, report: roots table (issues, fix shape, state), closures with rule+evidence, borderline list with reasons, D-items and their answers, mechanism-map mismatches found, and the meta-issue comment link.

References

• ../rdd-advisory-transport/references/shared-advisory-transport-proposal.md — exemplar proposal shape produced by this method.
• ../rdd-advisory-transport/references/issue-impact-matrix.md — exemplar per-issue disposition matrix.