self-audit

Self-Audit: Can This Plugin Be Replaced?

Check whether a community plugin now does what marketplace-evaluator does, and whether this plugin should be improved or replaced.

Audit Process

Step 1: Define Own Capabilities

Read this plugin's skills and agents to enumerate what it provides:

1. Marketplace screening across multiple marketplaces
2. Goal-based evaluation with configurable criteria
3. Multi-model deep review (Claude + Codex)
4. Persistent repo-based output (JSON + markdown)
5. Meta-learning from past evaluations
6. Self-audit for replacement detection

Step 2: Search for Competitors

1. Read the latest evaluations JSON for plugins tagged with plugin-finding or plugin-management goals
2. Search marketplace descriptions for keywords: "evaluate plugins", "plugin audit", "marketplace scan", "skill doctor", "plugin manager"
3. Check installed plugins for overlapping capabilities

Step 3: Compare

For each candidate competitor:

Criterion	marketplace-evaluator	Competitor
Multi-marketplace scan	Yes/No	Yes/No
Goal-based filtering	Yes/No	Yes/No
Multi-model review	Yes/No	Yes/No
Repo-persisted output	Yes/No	Yes/No
Meta-learning	Yes/No	Yes/No
Self-audit	Yes/No	Yes/No

Step 4: Recommend

• KEEP: No competitor covers all capabilities
• IMPROVE: Competitor does X better — extract pattern, add to this plugin
• REPLACE: Competitor fully supersedes this plugin — recommend migration plan

Step 5: Report

Self-Audit Report
=================
Competitors found: N
Closest match: plugin-name (covers 4/6 capabilities)
Recommendation: KEEP | IMPROVE | REPLACE
Details: [explanation]